dexron-III vs. regular power steering fluid
#1
dexron-III vs. regular power steering fluid
I was about to change my power steering fluid (using the suck-out and refill method) when I noticed that the fluid in the reservoir was not red -- as in DEXRON-III RED. I know that the fluid could be any color regardless of spec, but i have a weired suspicion that someone has poured the "regular" (goldish) power steering fluid in there.
I have a couple of questions.
1) What are the repercussions of mixing (at least to some degree) Dexron-iii and regular power steering fluid.
2) What are the chances that that the fluid in there -- even though the color is not red is actually Dexron-III (the car was most likely serviced by the dealer until i bought it)
I'm the second owner of this 2007 XJ8 VDP and it has 83000 miles on it.
I have a couple of questions.
1) What are the repercussions of mixing (at least to some degree) Dexron-iii and regular power steering fluid.
2) What are the chances that that the fluid in there -- even though the color is not red is actually Dexron-III (the car was most likely serviced by the dealer until i bought it)
I'm the second owner of this 2007 XJ8 VDP and it has 83000 miles on it.
#2
#3
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,743
Received 10,757 Likes
on
7,101 Posts
I've often meant to research the properties of official "power steering fluid" and compare the results to Dex III (or any other ATF). One day I will....unless an authority chimes in here and saves me the trouble :-).
On other (non-Jaguar) cars I've mixed p/s fluid and ATF and noticed no ill results. That is, nothing horrible happened, at least in the short term. I'm not sure about possible long term problems but I have doubts that any would crop up.
Dex III is specified for power steering in my '95 and same for my older (80s vintage) Jags. I've always used whatever ATF I had on hand at the time. Right now I have an excess inventory of Type "F" and it seems to work perfectly well <shrug>.
Interestingly the older Jags used GM/Saginaw power steering pumps. GM recommends only power steering fluid while Jaguar used ATF. Go figure, eh? Of course, besides the pump there's always the question of what the rack and pinion needs or likes by way of lubricant.
My non-authoritative conclusion is that power steering systems, at least on older models, simply are not very sensitive with respect to what type of fluid is used. Newer cars may well have more sophisticated and critical requirements.
Sorry for the rambling non-answer :-)
Cheers
DD
On other (non-Jaguar) cars I've mixed p/s fluid and ATF and noticed no ill results. That is, nothing horrible happened, at least in the short term. I'm not sure about possible long term problems but I have doubts that any would crop up.
Dex III is specified for power steering in my '95 and same for my older (80s vintage) Jags. I've always used whatever ATF I had on hand at the time. Right now I have an excess inventory of Type "F" and it seems to work perfectly well <shrug>.
Interestingly the older Jags used GM/Saginaw power steering pumps. GM recommends only power steering fluid while Jaguar used ATF. Go figure, eh? Of course, besides the pump there's always the question of what the rack and pinion needs or likes by way of lubricant.
My non-authoritative conclusion is that power steering systems, at least on older models, simply are not very sensitive with respect to what type of fluid is used. Newer cars may well have more sophisticated and critical requirements.
Sorry for the rambling non-answer :-)
Cheers
DD
#4
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,743
Received 10,757 Likes
on
7,101 Posts
#6
I've sucked out around 350 ml. of whatever was in the power steering reservoir --- and filled it with standard GM ATF (dexron-iii).... We shall see what happens --- I'll drive back and forth to work tomorrow and will repeat the procedure. So far, after a 10 km. test-drive I did not notice any issues.
Best regards,
-Chris
Best regards,
-Chris
Last edited by penguin; 09-14-2011 at 08:20 AM.
#7
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,743
Received 10,757 Likes
on
7,101 Posts
I've sucked out around 350 ml. of whatever was in the power steering reservoir --- and filled it with standard GM ATF (dexron-iii).... We shall see what happens --- I'll drive back and forth to work tomorrow and will repeat the procedure. So far, after a 10 km. test-drive I did not notice any issues.
Best regards,
-Chrsi
Best regards,
-Chrsi
Is Dexron the factory recommendation for your car? Just wondering.
Cheers
DD
Trending Topics
#8
#9
#10
#11
Castrol is an excellent product and has been favoured by Jaguar for years.
What i would reccomend is the addition of a bottle of LUCAS Power Steering Conditioner...this stuff is brilliant ;o))
As for fluid loosing it's colour, yes, it will over time as a normal practice with working fluid....leave it long enough and it will go very dark.
A PS system in good condition should only need it's fluid changing every three years or so.
It's always good practice when replacing fluid to jack front wheels just far enough off the deck to be able run engine and turn the steering from lock to lock several times to bleed the system of any air that may get trapped in the system.
Cheers,
Maximus
The following users liked this post:
jahummer (03-07-2012)
#12
#13
Steering nibble.
Mine does exactly that. No noise. Just a slight nibble in the steering wheel a few degrees off center either side, like jayhummer's.
I just went to napa and bought the suction gun andsome royal purple pwr strg
Fluid to make the change.
Noticed it more in warmer weather, just like somebody else posted. 2005 45,000 mile XJ8 vdp.
I just went to napa and bought the suction gun andsome royal purple pwr strg
Fluid to make the change.
Noticed it more in warmer weather, just like somebody else posted. 2005 45,000 mile XJ8 vdp.
#15
Years ago, my steering had a shudder in it when turning the wheel, changing the fluid out to Mobil 1 ATF solved it.
#16
For the matrix, I disconnected the return line from the rack and did a flush of fluid using the action of turning the steering wheel. For the S-Type, there is a hose coming off the rack that seemed like a pretty good place to drain the fluid, also flushing by working the steering wheel. After doing this, the squeeking became more prevalent, so I guess I should add the magic liquid now.
#17
#18
The following 2 users liked this post by JagV8:
ForTheLoveOfCars (02-04-2024),
Xeno (07-20-2023)
#19
The following users liked this post:
ForTheLoveOfCars (02-04-2024)
#20
Thank you! Knowing that the title is "Vehicle Specifications" enabled me to find one for my car (and for all Jaguar models made in 2004) here. I think yours covers the X358, and the one from 2004 covers the X350. (It doesn't say.)
Oddly, even the Vehicle Specifications doesn't say anything about brakes or brake fluid.
Oddly, even the Vehicle Specifications doesn't say anything about brakes or brake fluid.
Last edited by Xeno; 07-20-2023 at 12:57 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)