Pros / Cons to removing hood liner
#1
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
Pros / Cons to removing hood liner
OK, has anyone done this ?
I have the same issue as these people; the liner is abrading the intercooler hose(s) too the point I'm worried about a hose failure. I put a sleeve over the affected area made from an old heater hose slit down the length. Not a really good solution as the extra diameter just puts more pressure on the temp. sending units wiring which are directly under the intercooler hoses :
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/x...-engine-44163/
My hood needs a repaint anyway, so I'm not too concerned with heat damage, although I don't think that is going to be a problem. I've had many many cars, including e types and Shelby's that normally ran moderately hot, 210-220. And they had no hood liner and no paint damage from heat.
I'm pretty sure there will be more engine noise, but as it's too darn quiet anyway, so thats a plus for me.
So, anyone just remove the whole liner ? in the the topic referenced above, some people just cut out the hood liner where it was making contact with the hoses. To me, I'd rather just take off the whole thing than hack it up.
Z
I have the same issue as these people; the liner is abrading the intercooler hose(s) too the point I'm worried about a hose failure. I put a sleeve over the affected area made from an old heater hose slit down the length. Not a really good solution as the extra diameter just puts more pressure on the temp. sending units wiring which are directly under the intercooler hoses :
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/x...-engine-44163/
My hood needs a repaint anyway, so I'm not too concerned with heat damage, although I don't think that is going to be a problem. I've had many many cars, including e types and Shelby's that normally ran moderately hot, 210-220. And they had no hood liner and no paint damage from heat.
I'm pretty sure there will be more engine noise, but as it's too darn quiet anyway, so thats a plus for me.
So, anyone just remove the whole liner ? in the the topic referenced above, some people just cut out the hood liner where it was making contact with the hoses. To me, I'd rather just take off the whole thing than hack it up.
Z
#2
Z,
I owned an XJ6 for a while. I removed the hood liner from that car - little did I know it provided protection from an engine heat source. I don't recall exactly what produced this heat on that model, but bad news. The paint on the outside of the hood bubbled within a week or two!
I cant think of anything that could go wrong on the xk8, but good thing to ask.
If there's something that might be problematic I'm sure it'll come out with the combined knowledge here.
John
I owned an XJ6 for a while. I removed the hood liner from that car - little did I know it provided protection from an engine heat source. I don't recall exactly what produced this heat on that model, but bad news. The paint on the outside of the hood bubbled within a week or two!
I cant think of anything that could go wrong on the xk8, but good thing to ask.
If there's something that might be problematic I'm sure it'll come out with the combined knowledge here.
John
Last edited by Johnken; 08-15-2018 at 11:55 PM.
#4
Seems unlikely that contact with the liner was by design.
Removing the liner will probably affect the paint on the exterior of the hood.
Gluing the liner to the inside of the hood reduces the overall heat insulation a bit but must be okay since there are no reports of negative effects.
What is it with XKR owners wanting their cars to make more noise? Usually it is exhaust. Now even louder engine rattles & whines are desirable? It's a noticeable trend in the threads.
How about a picture of the "damage"? Even in the referenced thread I could find no pic of the contact point.
Is it possible that the hydraulic engine mounts are failing to keep the engine stable and allowing the contact?
Is the liner sagging such that it could be fixed by adding more retainers (P/N KRS113130). I added a few to mine to keep the edges from drooping.
#5
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
Ok a few thoughts.
Seems unlikely that contact with the liner was by design.
Removing the liner will probably affect the paint on the exterior of the hood.
Gluing the liner to the inside of the hood reduces the overall heat insulation a bit but must be okay since there are no reports of negative effects.
What is it with XKR owners wanting their cars to make more noise? Usually it is exhaust. Now even louder engine rattles & whines are desirable? It's a noticeable trend in the threads.
How about a picture of the "damage"? Even in the referenced thread I could find no pic of the contact point.
Is it possible that the hydraulic engine mounts are failing to keep the engine stable and allowing the contact?
Is the liner sagging such that it could be fixed by adding more retainers (P/N KRS113130). I added a few to mine to keep the edges from drooping.
Seems unlikely that contact with the liner was by design.
Removing the liner will probably affect the paint on the exterior of the hood.
Gluing the liner to the inside of the hood reduces the overall heat insulation a bit but must be okay since there are no reports of negative effects.
What is it with XKR owners wanting their cars to make more noise? Usually it is exhaust. Now even louder engine rattles & whines are desirable? It's a noticeable trend in the threads.
How about a picture of the "damage"? Even in the referenced thread I could find no pic of the contact point.
Is it possible that the hydraulic engine mounts are failing to keep the engine stable and allowing the contact?
Is the liner sagging such that it could be fixed by adding more retainers (P/N KRS113130). I added a few to mine to keep the edges from drooping.
thank you for the observations.
All hood liner screws in place, and no drooping in the areas of contact. I can push on the hood liner and there is no movement. So it appears to be as close up tight to the hood as possible.
Motor mounts show no signs of movement
The hood liner looks as though it has actually melted from the contact with the (hot) intercooler hose(s). There is one major point of contact on one hose / liner location and a couple of minor points of contact on another hose.
Here are some photos. The light areas of the hood liner are where it is making contact with the hoses. The last photo is of the hose showing the most contact and abrasion.
Z.
#6
Hi,
I removed the liner completely last year, my car is a 2000 Xkr. No issues with paint on the hood so far, maybe different colors affects differently. Mine is platinum grey. Here in northern Europe summers are not very warm but this one has been the warmest ever recorded, temperature regularly around 30 degrees celcius. So I guess in my case at least hood paint was not affected by removing the liner
Regards
Higgins
I removed the liner completely last year, my car is a 2000 Xkr. No issues with paint on the hood so far, maybe different colors affects differently. Mine is platinum grey. Here in northern Europe summers are not very warm but this one has been the warmest ever recorded, temperature regularly around 30 degrees celcius. So I guess in my case at least hood paint was not affected by removing the liner
Regards
Higgins
#7
Thanks Z the pics are a big help.
This last pic makes me think the height of that hose is off due to the orientation of the coupler and rotation of the hose itself. That might have happened when previous owner did the tensioner work.
I would try to loosen that coupler and turn the outlet to point more horizontal instead of slightly up like it is now. Might get it down enough to clear the liner.
I found a pic that shows the hose routing that I think would be original. What do you think?
This last pic makes me think the height of that hose is off due to the orientation of the coupler and rotation of the hose itself. That might have happened when previous owner did the tensioner work.
I would try to loosen that coupler and turn the outlet to point more horizontal instead of slightly up like it is now. Might get it down enough to clear the liner.
I found a pic that shows the hose routing that I think would be original. What do you think?
The following users liked this post:
zray (08-18-2018)
Trending Topics
#8
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
Hi,
I removed the liner completely last year, my car is a 2000 Xkr. No issues with paint on the hood so far, maybe different colors affects differently. Mine is platinum grey. Here in northern Europe summers are not very warm but this one has been the warmest ever recorded, temperature regularly around 30 degrees celcius. So I guess in my case at least hood paint was not affected by removing the liner
Regarads
Higgins
I removed the liner completely last year, my car is a 2000 Xkr. No issues with paint on the hood so far, maybe different colors affects differently. Mine is platinum grey. Here in northern Europe summers are not very warm but this one has been the warmest ever recorded, temperature regularly around 30 degrees celcius. So I guess in my case at least hood paint was not affected by removing the liner
Regarads
Higgins
Just curious, what prompted you to remove the liner ?
Thanks Z the pics are a big help.
This last pic makes me think the height of that hose is off due to the orientation of the coupler and rotation of the hose itself. That might have happened when previous owner did the tensioner work.
I would try to loosen that coupler and turn the outlet to point more horizontal instead of slightly up like it is now. Might get it down enough to clear the liner.
I found a pic that shows the hose routing that I think would be original. What do you think?
This last pic makes me think the height of that hose is off due to the orientation of the coupler and rotation of the hose itself. That might have happened when previous owner did the tensioner work.
I would try to loosen that coupler and turn the outlet to point more horizontal instead of slightly up like it is now. Might get it down enough to clear the liner.
I found a pic that shows the hose routing that I think would be original. What do you think?
thats a good suggestion. However, the hose is already resting on the wiring and temp sensor under it at the area of contact. I've tried pushing it down slightly in that spot, but there's nowhere for it to move to, so the height of the hose is as low as it can go regardless of the hose orientation. Too bad, as a little downward movement would take care of things nicely.
Nevertheless, I think I'll investigate a possible orientation change to see if it matters
in the photo you provided it looks like someone has put a plastic ring around the spot where the rubbing / abrasions occur. Interesting !
Z
Last edited by zray; 08-17-2018 at 04:36 PM.
#9
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
Rothwell, I took your suggestion and loosened the hose fitting and rotated the hose on the passenger side intercooler hose connection so the T fitting area is level or slightly pointing downward.
Unable to tell initially what difference it will make, so I wrapped three circles of one inch masking tape about 1/2" apart along the area of hose / hood liner contact. If the masking tape abraded, then I still have a problem. If it doesn't abrade, then it's fixed and it goes without saying that you are genius.
Z
Unable to tell initially what difference it will make, so I wrapped three circles of one inch masking tape about 1/2" apart along the area of hose / hood liner contact. If the masking tape abraded, then I still have a problem. If it doesn't abrade, then it's fixed and it goes without saying that you are genius.
Z
Last edited by zray; 08-18-2018 at 08:25 AM. Reason: Misc. corrections
#10
Zray,
The reason I removed the liner is because I changed the air intake tube between air filter box and throttle body to a less restrictive one from Mina Gallery. I then had issues with closing the hood, so I removed the liner to solve the issue. Just like you, I dont mind a little more noise. Infact the slight increased levels of noise is like music to my ears :-)
Regards
Higgins
The reason I removed the liner is because I changed the air intake tube between air filter box and throttle body to a less restrictive one from Mina Gallery. I then had issues with closing the hood, so I removed the liner to solve the issue. Just like you, I dont mind a little more noise. Infact the slight increased levels of noise is like music to my ears :-)
Regards
Higgins
The following users liked this post:
zray (08-18-2018)
#11
Rothwell, I took your suggestion and loosened the hose fitting and rotated the hose on the passenger side intercooler hose connection so the T fitting area is level or slightly pointing downward.
Unable to tell initially what difference it will make, so I wrapped three circles of one inch masking tape about 1/2" apart along the area of hose / hood liner contact. If the masking tape abraded, then I still have a problem. If it doesn't abrade, then it's fixed and it goes without saying that you are genius.
Z
Unable to tell initially what difference it will make, so I wrapped three circles of one inch masking tape about 1/2" apart along the area of hose / hood liner contact. If the masking tape abraded, then I still have a problem. If it doesn't abrade, then it's fixed and it goes without saying that you are genius.
Z
You could probably get a rough measure of the gap by using a small piece of cardboard with double sided tape on top that will stick to the liner if it touches. If the liner does not pick it up then add another layer of cardboard till it does.
Best of luck!
#12
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
From the looks of that hose it should not take long to see a result. Will be great if the solution is that simple.
You could probably get a rough measure of the gap by using a small piece of cardboard with double sided tape on top that will stick to the liner if it touches. If the liner does not pick it up then add another layer of cardboard till it does.
Best of luck!
You could probably get a rough measure of the gap by using a small piece of cardboard with double sided tape on top that will stick to the liner if it touches. If the liner does not pick it up then add another layer of cardboard till it does.
Best of luck!
Z
The following users liked this post:
rothwell (08-18-2018)
#13
#14
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
the hose is definately abrading. It has a flat spot over 3 inches long.
It's hard to tell if the hood liner is actually melting . I've looked at pretty closely and under some basic magnification and in my view it's melted in places.. The thread I referenced also mentioned melting.
Z
#15
the hose is definately abrading. It has a flat spot over 3 inches long.
It's hard to tell if the hood liner is actually melting . I've looked at pretty closely and under some basic magnification and in my view it's melted in places.. The thread I referenced also mentioned melting.
Z
#16
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,695
Received 1,578 Likes
on
945 Posts
All the fluid hoses going in and out of the intercooler get really hot, I don't have the exact numbers. The hose is definately abraded FLAT from the contact with the hood liner. No evidence of melted rubber hose on the liner or elsewhere. All of the posts on the thread referenced from 2010+ talk about their issues from hose abrasion too.
Many of them also fixed this issue by just cutting out the patch of the hood liner that was making contact. I'm not too enthusiastic about that. It may be extreme but I'd rather take off the liner than cut out a strip from the center of it. I'm keeping an eye on my test strips of masking tape. If they wear then I'll know my reorientation of the hose angle didn't do much.
Z
Many of them also fixed this issue by just cutting out the patch of the hood liner that was making contact. I'm not too enthusiastic about that. It may be extreme but I'd rather take off the liner than cut out a strip from the center of it. I'm keeping an eye on my test strips of masking tape. If they wear then I'll know my reorientation of the hose angle didn't do much.
Z
#17
on my XK8 there is some rubbing on the plastic intake manifold, so it is a possibility. one day i might either upgrade to a better hood insulator or refinish the underside of the hood to make it look nice without. you might want to try something from this page as an option. the foil finish protectors also look very nice.
https://www.jegs.com/c/Fittings-Hose...01707/10002/-1
https://www.jegs.com/c/Fittings-Hose...01707/10002/-1
The following users liked this post:
Broom (08-18-2019)
#18
Intake vent wore through from the blanket
I just replaced my intake. The blanket wore all the tops of the ridges off. I was thinking about using gasket maker to seal it but I wasn’t sure about it so I found one off a parts car.
i would like to sort the blanket out. It’s buffing the top of the engine cover. I figure it’s from the engine vibration rubbing against the hood blanket.
Anyone know a good way to take the sag out?
i have three ideas but not sure which is best.
i would like to sort the blanket out. It’s buffing the top of the engine cover. I figure it’s from the engine vibration rubbing against the hood blanket.
Anyone know a good way to take the sag out?
i have three ideas but not sure which is best.
- Use double sided tape underside of hood? Not sure if it would hold up or just start to sag shortly. Any idea of good tape?
- use some clips underside of hood. Not sure of anything that is available
- bend stiff wire and mount under blanket by the screws that hold the blanket up. But could caused more damage if engine is rubbing on the wire.
#19
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)