Elevated idle speed when started from cold
#1
Elevated idle speed when started from cold
On my 2001 XKR I have been noticing lately that when starting from cold with ambient temperatures in the region of 17-18°C the car first revs up to an indicated 1400RPM approx, for 20 seconds or so, before dropping back down to a normal idle speed.
I've seen the TSB that states that in the 20°C range normal RPM is increased by 220 RPM for 20 seconds, which makes 1150rpm. Even allowing for my rev counter to be over reading, it does seem quite high.
There are no codes on the engine, long term fuel trims aren't particulary high, the car has had new spark plugs, the throttle body has been cleaned, the MAF sensor has been cleaned and so on, so does anyone have any suggestions as to what could be causing this, as I really don't like the car reving so high from a cold start?
TIA
I've seen the TSB that states that in the 20°C range normal RPM is increased by 220 RPM for 20 seconds, which makes 1150rpm. Even allowing for my rev counter to be over reading, it does seem quite high.
There are no codes on the engine, long term fuel trims aren't particulary high, the car has had new spark plugs, the throttle body has been cleaned, the MAF sensor has been cleaned and so on, so does anyone have any suggestions as to what could be causing this, as I really don't like the car reving so high from a cold start?
TIA
#2
#3
I've been working on my car a lot recently and disconnected the battery each time for safety. After an extended work session, I noticed that when I reconnect the battery and start the car from cold, the initial engine rev is a lot higher than normal, then settles down quickly to around 1400rpm and then down to idle. However the next time I start the car, the initial rev is only 1400 for approx. 15sec and then settles down to idle.
I never start driving the car until the idle rpm speed is reached which isn't long in Bahrain as it's quite warm.
I never start driving the car until the idle rpm speed is reached which isn't long in Bahrain as it's quite warm.
#5
Join Date: Jan 2018
Location: on the road in NE Oklahoma
Posts: 2,683
Received 1,566 Likes
on
938 Posts
I've been working on my car a lot recently and disconnected the battery each time for safety. After an extended work session, I noticed that when I reconnect the battery and start the car from cold, the initial engine rev is a lot higher than normal, then settles down quickly to around 1400rpm and then down to idle. However the next time I start the car, the initial rev is only 1400 for approx. 15sec and then settles down to idle?......."
Z
#6
The following users liked this post:
zray (12-30-2022)
#7
+2 Zray
@dibbit OP -- what you are observing is most often caused by dripping injectors. try some Techron fuel cleaner 2 or 3 times before your next oil change, one in each tank of fuel before filling, run the tank to 1/8 before next. this might make a difference. otherwise, having the injectors serviced is not very costly and they are easy to remove.
@dibbit OP -- what you are observing is most often caused by dripping injectors. try some Techron fuel cleaner 2 or 3 times before your next oil change, one in each tank of fuel before filling, run the tank to 1/8 before next. this might make a difference. otherwise, having the injectors serviced is not very costly and they are easy to remove.
Trending Topics
#8
Something may be amiss, but I don't think so.
when you are at a warm idle, what does the throttle position sensor read ? Anything under 2% is normal.
it may be aggravating to you, but I don't think it's excessive. Now if this a new phenomenon then., yes, something has changed..
Z
when you are at a warm idle, what does the throttle position sensor read ? Anything under 2% is normal.
it may be aggravating to you, but I don't think it's excessive. Now if this a new phenomenon then., yes, something has changed..
Z
+2 Zray
@dibbit OP -- what you are observing is most often caused by dripping injectors. try some Techron fuel cleaner 2 or 3 times before your next oil change, one in each tank of fuel before filling, run the tank to 1/8 before next. this might make a difference. otherwise, having the injectors serviced is not very costly and they are easy to remove.
@dibbit OP -- what you are observing is most often caused by dripping injectors. try some Techron fuel cleaner 2 or 3 times before your next oil change, one in each tank of fuel before filling, run the tank to 1/8 before next. this might make a difference. otherwise, having the injectors serviced is not very costly and they are easy to remove.
#9
Also, some have reported that after disconnecting the instrument cluster, some gauges were reading off (needle offset somehow). I believe a "hard reset" cures these problems. Maybe a weak battery is somehow making your tach a bit off. If you are OK dealing with OBD monitors needing to set again, try the said "Hard Reset" and see what happens.
Separately, the real rpm value should be available over OBDII for confirmation A cheap ELM327 will read this.
Best of luck, keep us posted.
Separately, the real rpm value should be available over OBDII for confirmation A cheap ELM327 will read this.
Best of luck, keep us posted.
#10
Also, some have reported that after disconnecting the instrument cluster, some gauges were reading off (needle offset somehow). I believe a "hard reset" cures these problems. Maybe a weak battery is somehow making your tach a bit off. If you are OK dealing with OBD monitors needing to set again, try the said "Hard Reset" and see what happens.
Separately, the real rpm value should be available over OBDII for confirmation A cheap ELM327 will read this.
Best of luck, keep us posted.
Separately, the real rpm value should be available over OBDII for confirmation A cheap ELM327 will read this.
Best of luck, keep us posted.
I've attached a screen grab from Dash Commander at idle when warm for info (short term trims around 0%). The throttle position was reported as 2.7%.
#11
#12
I'm pretty certain the throttle is correctly adjusted, but I will check the value just in case. This is only happening now due to the winter temperatures - during the rest of the year the ambient temperature is high enough not to be in the elevated idle range, so I'm not sure if anything else has changed since last winter.
I did try a can of BG44K last year, which made a difference to the smoothness of the engine - do you think it's worth trying more cleaner?
I did try a can of BG44K last year, which made a difference to the smoothness of the engine - do you think it's worth trying more cleaner?
#13
Reiterating what others said above, if you're disconnecting the battery, the ecm is having to relearn when you start it the first time. That initial high idle is absolutely what you would expect to see each time.
If you continue to have that problem every time you start afterwards without having disconnected the battery again, then you perhaps have an issue.
A slight leak in the intake system will cause an initial high idle until the trims correct it.
If you continue to have that problem every time you start afterwards without having disconnected the battery again, then you perhaps have an issue.
A slight leak in the intake system will cause an initial high idle until the trims correct it.
#14
Reiterating what others said above, if you're disconnecting the battery, the ecm is having to relearn when you start it the first time. That initial high idle is absolutely what you would expect to see each time.
If you continue to have that problem every time you start afterwards without having disconnected the battery again, then you perhaps have an issue.
A slight leak in the intake system will cause an initial high idle until the trims correct it.
If you continue to have that problem every time you start afterwards without having disconnected the battery again, then you perhaps have an issue.
A slight leak in the intake system will cause an initial high idle until the trims correct it.
Last edited by dibbit; 02-16-2019 at 10:51 AM.
#15
#16
#17
Thanks. Today both LTFTs were at about 5% after driving the car. I changed the fuel filter last year - I intend to check the fuel pressure once I've got myself a gauge that fits the schrader valve - its on the to do list.
#18
I'm suffering the same issue on my XK8 4.2 and i assume it developed over the years. Now it takes about 40 secs till the idle speed drops from initial 1400 to first 1100 and then 900 and 650 when warmed up. I dont like to shift the gear in as long as the engine revs at 1400.
I don't think that it is caused by leaking injectors or false air because if so you would recognize other issues as unstable idle or warm start problems. i've checked the coolant and the intake air temperature sensors by resistance measuring and found them in good working order. my clue is now that the EMC is supposed to elevate the idle speed in order to get better emission results by warming up the catalysts faster. maybe this is an result of worn lambda sensors.
I have a lack of phantasy to see other input signals that could cause the EMC to lift up idle after cold start.
Fritz
I don't think that it is caused by leaking injectors or false air because if so you would recognize other issues as unstable idle or warm start problems. i've checked the coolant and the intake air temperature sensors by resistance measuring and found them in good working order. my clue is now that the EMC is supposed to elevate the idle speed in order to get better emission results by warming up the catalysts faster. maybe this is an result of worn lambda sensors.
I have a lack of phantasy to see other input signals that could cause the EMC to lift up idle after cold start.
Fritz
Last edited by flatsix; 02-18-2019 at 03:50 AM.
The following users liked this post:
DavidYau (02-18-2019)
#19
Someone suggested to me that this could be an early symptom that the valve in the EVAP Purge canister could be on the way out. Error code P0445 on the OBD when it goes. Access is easy via the front left wheel well liner and simple to replace. Part is inexpensive as well.
It's better/cheaper than replacing the CATS which needs dismantling the exhaust.
It's better/cheaper than replacing the CATS which needs dismantling the exhaust.
#20
I'm suffering the same issue on my XK8 4.2 and i assume it developed over the years. Now it takes about 40 secs till the idle speed drops from initial 1400 to first 1100 and then 900 and 650 when warmed up. I dont like to shift the gear in as long as the engine revs at 1400.
I don't think that it is caused by leaking injectors or false air because if so you would recognize other issues as unstable idle or warm start problems. i've checked the coolant and the intake air temperature sensors by resistance measuring and found them in good working order. my clue is now that the EMC is supposed to elevate the idle speed in order to get better emission results by warming up the catalysts faster. maybe this is an result of worn lambda sensors.
I have a lack of phantasy to see other input signals that could cause the EMC to lift up idle after cold start.
Fritz
I don't think that it is caused by leaking injectors or false air because if so you would recognize other issues as unstable idle or warm start problems. i've checked the coolant and the intake air temperature sensors by resistance measuring and found them in good working order. my clue is now that the EMC is supposed to elevate the idle speed in order to get better emission results by warming up the catalysts faster. maybe this is an result of worn lambda sensors.
I have a lack of phantasy to see other input signals that could cause the EMC to lift up idle after cold start.
Fritz