Jaguar Forums - Jaguar Enthusiasts Forum

Jaguar Forums - Jaguar Enthusiasts Forum (https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/)
-   XJ XJ8 / XJR ( X308 ) (https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/xj-xj8-xjr-x308-27/)
-   -   Problems at speed (https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/xj-xj8-xjr-x308-27/problems-speed-212084/)

John Baker 12-25-2018 09:55 AM

Problems at speed
 
My 99 XJ8 with 81K miles I bought last month seems to be having some trouble that starts around 70MPH. It starts a low grumble that builds and slight loss of power. It doesn't start right away, usually takes about 15 minutes or so of driving at that speed. If I try to accelerate through it, it just gets worse. If I throw the gear selector over from D to 4 it gets much better, but still some vibration. No warning lights of any kind come up which is surprising to me because of how hard it starts to shake if you push it.
These issues are not present at slower speeds, it only happens on the interstate speeds

M. Stojanovic 12-25-2018 07:19 PM

It seems to be ignition related (loss of one or two cylinders). I would first replace the spark plugs.

John Baker 12-25-2018 09:12 PM

Thanks spark plugs were already replaced with NGKs. Would an ignition problem like a bad coil throw a code ?

ericjansen 12-25-2018 10:11 PM

Fuel starvation? Clogged fuel system?

M. Stojanovic 12-25-2018 10:56 PM


Originally Posted by John Baker (Post 2005382)
Thanks spark plugs were already replaced with NGKs. Would an ignition problem like a bad coil throw a code ?

I believe that a bad coil will, in most cases, throw a code but there may be cases, depending on how the coil fails, that it may not. I had a couple of cases with conventional ignition coils where, when cold, the coils would function well but, when they heated up after some time of driving, they would cause loss of power and have exactly the same symptom as what you described - the engine will run fairly well at a constant speed but it would not accelerate (it would tend to go down in rpm when you press the accelerator further). These were cases where the coils were still functioning but, when they heated-up, they would produce a somewhat weaker spark which cannot support acceleration. It is possible that coils producing weakened spark will not be recognised by the ECU.

However, your problem could also be due to fuel starvation (as mentioned by Eric) but this should normally not be heat related.

John Baker 12-26-2018 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by ericjansen (Post 2005391)
Fuel starvation? Clogged fuel system?

Hmm I did just replace the fuel filter, it appeared original and clogged up. I noticed the car idled so much better when replaced. I guess the next step is to measure the fuel pressure

John Baker 12-26-2018 08:44 AM


Originally Posted by M. Stojanovic (Post 2005398)
I believe that a bad coil will, in most cases, throw a code but there may be cases, depending on how the coil fails, that it may not. I had a couple of cases with conventional ignition coils where, when cold, the coils would function well but, when they heated up after some time of driving, they would cause loss of power and have exactly the same symptom as what you described - the engine will run fairly well at a constant speed but it would not accelerate (it would tend to go down in rpm when you press the accelerator further). These were cases where the coils were still functioning but, when they heated-up, they would produce a somewhat weaker spark which cannot support acceleration. It is possible that coils producing weakened spark will not be recognised by the ECU.

However, your problem could also be due to fuel starvation (as mentioned by Eric) but this should normally not be heat related.

Hmm OK do you have any suggestions on how to trouble shoot that besides just buying new coils?

John Baker 12-26-2018 04:23 PM

I just measured a nice steady 41 PSI at the fuel rail with the vacuum hose removed from the regulator. So i dont think its a fuel problem.

M. Stojanovic 12-26-2018 07:48 PM


Originally Posted by John Baker (Post 2005476)
Hmm OK do you have any suggestions on how to trouble shoot that besides just buying new coils?

Very hard to find out which coils are bad if they only start partially failing (reduced spark) when they heat up. This kind of problem is usually in their secondary windings (very thin wire) due to insulation deterioration. You can try measuring the secondary coil resistances on all coils and compare them; perhaps this will tell you something.

Since you probably have 4-wire coils, they have some electronics inside which could also be the reason for poor spark when heated up. Perhaps you can buy, say, 4 used coils and swap your coils one side first, test, then the other.

JagV8 12-27-2018 03:12 AM

You can test COPs (using a COP tester) but commonly people buy one or more known good ones and proceed as just posted.

John Baker 12-29-2018 07:25 PM

OK thanks guys, I ordered 4 for testing from here that is suppose to be decent used coils.

John Baker 01-05-2019 12:34 PM

Update I finally got these in the mail from the UK ebay seller. All but one looked new. I dropped 4 of them on the drivers side since it was the easiest to get to and headed out on the interstate for a test drive. It is definitely better thanks guys! I could just barely feel the old shaking at speed and I drove all the way to the next town to make sure it was completely warmed up. I'm going to go ahead and order 4 more for the other side since they are cheap and mine are obliviously bad.

Robman25 01-05-2019 03:52 PM

That’s a good price for those coils, I purchased 2 complete sets from china and so far they have performed extremely well.
this has been over 12 months with a few track sessions thrown in for good measure, last one being yesterday at (supposedly) the first race for 2019 in the world, in Taupo at the Bruce McLaren Park Race Way,we will discount any ice racing that may have occurred in the northern hemisphere :)

M. Stojanovic 01-06-2019 01:16 AM


Originally Posted by John Baker (Post 2009639)
Update I dropped 4 of them on the drivers side since it was the easiest to get to and headed out on the interstate for a test drive. I could just barely feel the old shaking at speed and I drove all the way to the next town to make sure it was completely warmed up.

"Barely feel the old shaking" probably means that you now have just one more bad coil somewhere. Either one of the 4 you bought or one of the 4 in the other bank. I'm sure that, with more used coils, you will find it. Another option is, having determined where the problem is, to now just buy 8 new coils. Aftermarket ones are, at Barratt for example, GBP 28 a piece.

Susie Q 10-01-2020 05:42 PM


Originally Posted by John Baker (Post 2005382)
Thanks spark plugs were already replaced with NGKs. Would an ignition problem like a bad coil throw a code ?

Yes, it's likely to show more than one, and you may see "restricted performance" message next to the check engine light.

JagV8 10-02-2020 07:10 AM


Originally Posted by John Baker (Post 2005382)
Would an ignition problem like a bad coil throw a code ?

If bad enough & occurring in near enough the same conditions, yes.
Otherwise, no.

Things can be wrong despite absence of codes, but when you do have codes something's wrong.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:57 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands