Suggestions and/or experience with brake pads that produce less dust?
#1
Suggestions and/or experience with brake pads that produce less dust?
I am needing to replace the front brake pads on my 2002 XJ8. In the past on other vehicles that I have owned (BMW, Mercedes, Buicks, etc.) I have had friends/forums recommend brake pads that produce less dust.
Now, I KNOW that there is always the argument that these pads, often called "dustless," are harder and will NOT perform as well. Discussions of them getting too hot, warping rotors, and decreasing braking have all be set forth. I DO understand both the theory and practical application of this, but will state that it has not been the case (at least not always) in the past. It certainly has not been the case in my applications.
Specifically, would anyone who has first hand knowledge about this like to comment? I would like this post to yield comparative results instead of a theoretical analysis. I certainly know that the latter does come into play in such a discussion though.
Thanks to all.
Now, I KNOW that there is always the argument that these pads, often called "dustless," are harder and will NOT perform as well. Discussions of them getting too hot, warping rotors, and decreasing braking have all be set forth. I DO understand both the theory and practical application of this, but will state that it has not been the case (at least not always) in the past. It certainly has not been the case in my applications.
Specifically, would anyone who has first hand knowledge about this like to comment? I would like this post to yield comparative results instead of a theoretical analysis. I certainly know that the latter does come into play in such a discussion though.
Thanks to all.
#2
The following 3 users liked this post by RJ237:
#3
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Crossroads of America
Posts: 19,391
Received 12,736 Likes
on
6,379 Posts
The following 4 users liked this post by Don B:
#4
#5
FCP Euro is where I got my Akebono ceramics from, they were fantastic to deal with
https://www.fcpeuro.com/
https://www.fcpeuro.com/
The following users liked this post:
Don B (02-06-2018)
#6
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Crossroads of America
Posts: 19,391
Received 12,736 Likes
on
6,379 Posts
Regarding the feel, I sometimes notice slightly more pedal pressure required with ceramic pads compared to OE semi-metallic or organic formulations, which tend to be on the softer side for optimal feel and stopping power. But within half a mile I'm already used to the new feel, so it's never an issue.
Rock Auto and Parts Geek offer good prices on Akebono and Centric, and for those who prefer OE pads, they also carry many of Jaguar's OEM brands, including Ate, Bendix, Ferodo, Jurid, Mintex, Textar and TRW.
Cheers,
Don
Last edited by Don B; 02-06-2018 at 07:57 PM.
The following 3 users liked this post by Don B:
#7
We have owned 4 Jaguars over the years; currently just have one, 2002 XJR. I have experimented with various pad and rotor combinations and found that my favorite is Akebono pads with Brembo rotors. I discovered Akebono back when I still had my BMW but they seem to be particularly well suited for the Jaguar cars.
I have several twists, turns and stops before I get out of my neighborhood so I guess they are warmed up before I ever really get to the serious driving. I think the pedal pressure required is slightly more but they still feel plenty responsive. They last really well and my wheels stay clean. I can't speak to rotor wear. I'm one of those weirdos that changes my rotors every time I change my pads.
I have several twists, turns and stops before I get out of my neighborhood so I guess they are warmed up before I ever really get to the serious driving. I think the pedal pressure required is slightly more but they still feel plenty responsive. They last really well and my wheels stay clean. I can't speak to rotor wear. I'm one of those weirdos that changes my rotors every time I change my pads.
The following users liked this post:
Don B (02-07-2018)
Trending Topics
#8
Back as I had my Volvo C30, I fitted EBC Greenstuff. It is supposed to produce a lot less dust. Well, it didn't. They just wore even quicker. The original ATE pads (no ceramic) held 100k km. The EBC a mere 40k km. I returned to ATE standard again... Sold the car with 207k km with more than 3/4 meat.
In my experience, less brake dust kx hard to accomplish. Either the compound is too hard or too soft. Hard for less wear or soft for larger particles.
I personnaly don't even care about them anymore. My rims are washed and since there are more intensive cleaners out there, burned in brake dust is a thing of the past.
In my experience, less brake dust kx hard to accomplish. Either the compound is too hard or too soft. Hard for less wear or soft for larger particles.
I personnaly don't even care about them anymore. My rims are washed and since there are more intensive cleaners out there, burned in brake dust is a thing of the past.
The following users liked this post:
Don B (02-07-2018)
#9
I buy centric ceramics and centric cheapy rotors on rockauto for a lot of vehicles, my own and other peoples cars. Akebono makes an excellent product and I would pick that over Centric if given the choice for the application.
I did centric front ceramic pads and front rotors on my non-Brembo XKR and it was $100 all in with eBay doing one of those 20 off 100 deals.
I did centric front ceramic pads and front rotors on my non-Brembo XKR and it was $100 all in with eBay doing one of those 20 off 100 deals.
The following users liked this post:
Don B (02-07-2018)
#11
Thanks for all the comments. In regards to the Centric ceramics, Rockauto, for instance, lists at least 5 different ceramics. Is there a specific one that anyone would recommend?
BTW, I gather that there are no brake pad wear sensors on my vehicle. Is there supposed to be an "audible" from a little metal tang that rubs up against the rotor when the pads are approaching replacement time? Now, I certainly understand a noise if the pad has worn thru, but I am talking about a specifically designed feature, as were not uncommon in the 70's-90's, that was designed to let the driver know to replace the pads.
BTW, I gather that there are no brake pad wear sensors on my vehicle. Is there supposed to be an "audible" from a little metal tang that rubs up against the rotor when the pads are approaching replacement time? Now, I certainly understand a noise if the pad has worn thru, but I am talking about a specifically designed feature, as were not uncommon in the 70's-90's, that was designed to let the driver know to replace the pads.
Last edited by robertjag; 02-10-2018 at 08:41 AM.
#12
Personally -- don't find the OE pads w/ OE rotors to be all the dusty on my R's ... much less vs my MB's .. and about the same as my Lexus vehicles with the OE Ake's
When I had them a DD -- I would get 25-30k on the front pads and replace the rotors on the second go around (no cutting) rears would go at least 75k. And this was going in and out of the city often.
Don't remember any sensors. The germans love sensors ... my Porsches go off with 40% remaining .. hate those things. GM loved the noise maker -- and needed it.
When I had them a DD -- I would get 25-30k on the front pads and replace the rotors on the second go around (no cutting) rears would go at least 75k. And this was going in and out of the city often.
Don't remember any sensors. The germans love sensors ... my Porsches go off with 40% remaining .. hate those things. GM loved the noise maker -- and needed it.
The following users liked this post:
robertjag (02-16-2018)
#13
I'm bumping this to see if anyone can lend a comment or two on just which of the Centric ceramics they are using.
Thanks
Thanks
Thanks for all the comments. In regards to the Centric ceramics, Rockauto, for instance, lists at least 5 different ceramics. Is there a specific one that anyone would recommend?
BTW, I gather that there are no brake pad wear sensors on my vehicle. Is there supposed to be an "audible" from a little metal tang that rubs up against the rotor when the pads are approaching replacement time? Now, I certainly understand a noise if the pad has worn thru, but I am talking about a specifically designed feature, as were not uncommon in the 70's-90's, that was designed to let the driver know to replace the pads.
BTW, I gather that there are no brake pad wear sensors on my vehicle. Is there supposed to be an "audible" from a little metal tang that rubs up against the rotor when the pads are approaching replacement time? Now, I certainly understand a noise if the pad has worn thru, but I am talking about a specifically designed feature, as were not uncommon in the 70's-90's, that was designed to let the driver know to replace the pads.
#15
[QUOTE=robertjag;1837637]I am needing to replace the front brake pads on my 2002 XJ8. In the past on other vehicles that I have owned (BMW, Mercedes, Buicks, etc.) I have had friends/forums recommend brake pads that produce less dust......>>>
The only pads worth considering bar none are from Akebono.
They make ceramic pads specifically for XJ8's.
I have been using these pads for the last 7 years and completely eradicated
the dreaded black dust problem.
As for performance, I have had no problem and they are as responsive as any other pad.
Being ceramic, they will withstand a lot of heavy beraking....if you are that way inclined ;o))
The only pads worth considering bar none are from Akebono.
They make ceramic pads specifically for XJ8's.
I have been using these pads for the last 7 years and completely eradicated
the dreaded black dust problem.
As for performance, I have had no problem and they are as responsive as any other pad.
Being ceramic, they will withstand a lot of heavy beraking....if you are that way inclined ;o))
#16
The whole dust issue is over blown IMO. We always used spray wax on our euro vehicles when I was a kid ... use Rejex now ....past 20 odd years.
I think the last brake issue was back in the 80's on my 70's XJS hand me down -- the OE is stuff is great for not much of a premium. When engineers design a car they spend some time picking the components ... never understood why you buy a car for a level of performance and then cut corners.
I think the last brake issue was back in the 80's on my 70's XJS hand me down -- the OE is stuff is great for not much of a premium. When engineers design a car they spend some time picking the components ... never understood why you buy a car for a level of performance and then cut corners.
#17
Akebono/ Brembo rotors
for me are the only way to go... My 2003( x308) has Asteroid rims and with the original brakes they were getting covered with brake dust and needed cleaning far too often. I replaced the originals with a Brembo/Akebono package ...problem solved... minimal brake dust with braking not a whole lot different from OEM.
Comment on XJR brakes,,,,fair at best, This is a heavy car and I always get the feeling that the brakes aren't stopping the darned thing fast enough especially if you're trying to come down from going like hell. To me , its the biggest "weakness" of the car. The solution I read,is the dual piston caliper and drilled rotor option but also are outrageously expensive.
Bottom line for this car that I love is to drive it such that I leave plenty of room ahead to stop it
Comment on XJR brakes,,,,fair at best, This is a heavy car and I always get the feeling that the brakes aren't stopping the darned thing fast enough especially if you're trying to come down from going like hell. To me , its the biggest "weakness" of the car. The solution I read,is the dual piston caliper and drilled rotor option but also are outrageously expensive.
Bottom line for this car that I love is to drive it such that I leave plenty of room ahead to stop it
#19
for me are the only way to go... My 2003( x308) has Asteroid rims and with the original brakes they were getting covered with brake dust and needed cleaning far too often. I replaced the originals with a Brembo/Akebono package ...problem solved... minimal brake dust with braking not a whole lot different from OEM.
Comment on XJR brakes,,,,fair at best, This is a heavy car and I always get the feeling that the brakes aren't stopping the darned thing fast enough especially if you're trying to come down from going like hell. To me , its the biggest "weakness" of the car. The solution I read,is the dual piston caliper and drilled rotor option but also are outrageously expensive.
Bottom line for this car that I love is to drive it such that I leave plenty of room ahead to stop it
Comment on XJR brakes,,,,fair at best, This is a heavy car and I always get the feeling that the brakes aren't stopping the darned thing fast enough especially if you're trying to come down from going like hell. To me , its the biggest "weakness" of the car. The solution I read,is the dual piston caliper and drilled rotor option but also are outrageously expensive.
Bottom line for this car that I love is to drive it such that I leave plenty of room ahead to stop it
Jaguars have always had wonderful brakes and the X308 R's are better. It's one of the items always mentioned in the reviews for the model. Now -- stopping also requires excellent tires ... if any warning lights are illuminating while braking the tires are not doing the job.
The X308's brakes have no problem stopping the car .. even from 100 miles an hour. Controlled.
both of mine are stock ... why mess with success.
The following users liked this post:
Don B (03-03-2018)
#20
Opinions vary...Tires are brand new original Pirellis all around.. rotors are new Brembos with new aKebono pads all around. All calipers recently bled with new dot 4 fluid replaced. There is NOTHING wrong with the brake system whatsoever.... just saying that in my opinion stopping this car that weighs over 2 tons from high speed with the "standard brakes" is SCARY. Control is fine with no problems there. Its just that it takes too long in my opinion.
Besides ,if the standard brakes are as great as you claim they are , why did Jaguar offer the R option ? Could it be that many owners had voiced the same concerns about "stopping power" that I have mentioned? As we all know the XJR is incredibly fast for its sheer size and weight. Stopping the damned thing ( without the "R" )package is another story. As said previously, with that in mind , I drive accordingly
Besides ,if the standard brakes are as great as you claim they are , why did Jaguar offer the R option ? Could it be that many owners had voiced the same concerns about "stopping power" that I have mentioned? As we all know the XJR is incredibly fast for its sheer size and weight. Stopping the damned thing ( without the "R" )package is another story. As said previously, with that in mind , I drive accordingly