I've been driving a Jag long enough to know upkeep is a big part of the equation. My current 98 VDP is about due a replacment and I'm having a hard time deciding. I've already tried out both and the XK is lots sexier but a little tight on head room, it's got a couple more years and a few more miles but it's still a tight call in my mind. I'm hoping somebody with a little experience in either can share their opinion. Thanks

The XK will take years off you.

and hold it's value a little better as it's already taken that 3 year hit. With certified warranty, it's still as good as new.