|
Rebuilding powerfold mirrors
25 Attachment(s)
If your powerfold mirror mechanism breaks, you used to have 2 options:
So I decided to go a third path and rebuild my powerfold mechanism myself. It is not cheap but still much cheaper than buying a new one. Futhermore, I discovered and cured the weak point of the design, I now have a powerfold mechanism which I believe will last for life. First of all the disassembly of the pivot. I will focus only on the difficulties:
You can see 2 diodes that very well could be burnt. If that is the case they need to be replaced by rectifier diode able to withstand 1A. I have been able to measure peak currents close to 1A when the mirror reaches final position. For those who want to understand this twin microswitch, first you need to understand that the power fold electical motor is controlled by the car body processor with just 2 wires. The car body processor applies 12V in the 2 wires for a duration longer than the time required for the mirror to reach position. In order the prevent burning the electrical motor or breaking gears, the twin microswitch shown below opens the circuit and closes another circuit in order to be ready for the inverse movement when the body processor will apply 12V with opposite polarity. It is key yo understand that the 2 pieces of the microswitch shown below stay still during all the time while the mirror is moving. The 2 pieces of the microswitch only slide, one with respect to the other, when the mirror stops at its final position. https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 A complete unfold/fold Cycle is depicted below (sorry there is a bit of french left, so you know where I am coming from ;-)) https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363829236 Now the last point consists in disassembling the gear set and the 3 frictions. This is done by uncrimping the black plastic gearset cover on top of the pivot (part #18 below) and removing a big stop washer (part 1 below, be carreful it is under load of 2 big springs and there are a lot of shims and friction rings ready to fly around). Once done you are in front of this:
With such damaged gears, at best the mirror only moves to position but is not able to operate the microswitch (noisy cracking gears at the end of the movement), or even worse, it is not able to move the mirror at all (gear noise all the time). This is only going to deteriorate rapidly. I decided to have a ring gear rebuilt in stainless steel. Here is the manufacturing process involving electro-erosion: https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 - Step 1, build the outline with a lathe - Step 2, build a copper electrode having the required gear shape with wire-cut method - Step 3, press the electrode in the stainless still ring (electro erosion) - Step 4, Cut the spurs with wire_cut method https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/a...ine=1363828026 Here is a rebuilt powerfold pivot with the stainless still ring gear, new diodes and silicon greased frictions: I can have stainless steel gears built on request and could consider rebuilding pivots if this job is too scary for you. Cheers, Bruno |
Great job!
You are possibly the only person who has ever documented the rebuild of a power fold mirror mechanism. |
work of god!! you are a graduate from MIT? I admit that there is no way for me to be able to do it
|
2 Attachment(s)
Bruno, superb work and write-up.
The powerfold is a box of tricks isn't it. The wrong or failed micro relays (lh healboard) will break the mechanical stops marked did you find yours in tact? I have to ask, what is the price of the stainless items? |
Hi Sean,
The stainless steel ring gear is €100 for the first (including shipping to France) €80 for the second. I paid them more than that but now that the guy has the electrode built, he can reuse it many times and that is the reduced rate he told me he would apply now on. You may want to order directly to him. If you are interested I PM his email to you. He can be paid with paypal. And with respect to the LH heelboard relays, both were present when I bought the car, just the fuse was burnt in the RH heelboard. I do not think a wrong of failed microrelay will damage the power fold mechanism if this is what you mean. But operating a powerfold mirror that does not work perfectly will most likely accelerate its deterioration. Cheers, Bruno |
Note that the stainless steel ring gear is not a replacement for the parts that you are showing in your picture. This is a replacement for part #21 on my first post.
|
Great Post
Hi
I have been looking into this problem for several months now, so many thanks for the great post. Is it possible to get the contact details for the manufacturer of the replacement stainless steel gear? |
MP sent to you topcatnew.
A few more details on the rebuilt: - I replaced the rectifier diodes on the back of part #22 (one was in short circuit) with this reference: MBR140SFT1G 40V 1A Schottky Rectifier Diode SOD-123FL (measured peak current around 0.7A when mirror reach end position)(2 per mirror needed). - I replaced the protection diodes on the electrical motor with this reference BZX55 type 500mW (0.5W) Zener Diode with a zener voltage of 20V (I made a guess for the 20V, needs to be higher than the highest voltage the car 12V may ever reach into normal conditions)(note: unlike the rectifier diodes, these ones are not mandatory for operation but they protect the car electronics from spikes that might be generated by the electrical motor, specially when it is stopped)(these diode were physically split in 2 parts on my original mirrors)(2 needed per mirror). One last note, on right side mirror, wires #1 and #7 are inverted on the 12 points connectors ( the rotation direction must be inverted on the right side versus the left side to get the symetrical movement). Needless to stay, the mirrors have been operating perfectly since then. |
1 Attachment(s)
Do you still offer the part 21?
i have just took everything apart and mine is in even worse state! |
Hi Rui,
I am glad you have been able to take it apart. I sent an MP with contact info for the "manufacturer". Cheers, Bruno |
Power Fold Mirror Gears to buy
bballarin has kindly offered to contact the manufacturer to make these gears and I have decided to buy them.
So far, I am getting 5 gears (NOT 5 sets) if anyone else do want them, please let me know so maybe we can get them cheaper overall. Price to order them originally was 100EUR for one, 80Euro for second. I am not sure how much lower the price will be for order of more than xx amount. Rui |
I just sent a quotation request for 5 gears.
|
Originally Posted by bballarin
(Post 1053122)
I just sent a quotation request for 5 gears.
|
No answers to my quotation request sent directly to manufacturer's personal email. I have just sent him another message via the forum where he used to be active.
|
Fantastic write up, I kind of understand how it works (I think) not that I could even attempt to build it! Genius level stuff. You should be working for Jaguar on a high consultancy wage with this knowledge.
Anyway to the point. One of my powerfold mirrors on my 1995 X300 doesnt work. How would I start to diagnose this? It doesnt make any sound or attempt to move at all so I assume its an electrical issue. Obviously it cant be the switch and its unlikely to be a fuse as I assume its the same fuse for both sides? Thankyou to who ever can help! Chris |
Hi Chris,
I am glad you like the post. My answer is for X308 but should not be much different on X300. There is only one 10 A Fuse and 2 micro relays (one for opening and one for closing). There are all below the rear right seat behind heelboard, the fuse is position 4. Microrelays look like this (cluster of 4, only 2 of them for power fold): http://i39.servimg.com/u/f39/15/44/56/21/untitl19.jpg You are right if one powerfold mirror is working it is likely not the fuse nor the relays. So unless there is a deffective wiring in the car, the issue is likely in the mirror itself. If you can remove the door panel, testing pins 1 and 7 for + or - 12V while the other mirror is folding will definitely tell that the issue is in the mirror (maybe the rectifier diodes, see above posts). |
Right. Thats on the list of things to try to fix. The Diodes look fairly well buried within the mechinism. Are the mirrors difficult to get off and do you need to remove all the wiring sheath to get to the diodes? I think the diodes seem like a possible weak point. Especially if they have 1A going through them.
Guess it could also be a bad earth. |
Hi Chris,
I do not know from your post if you have tested the presence of + or - 12V between pin 1 and 7 on the connector (car side) while the other mirror is folding. This is the first thing to do. If there is an earth issue, it would affect only one of the mirrors since you say the other mirror is working. There can't be earth contact issue on the mirror itself, both (alternatively + or minus) signals are travelling only on wires inside the mirror (but there could be cut or short-circuit wires, or deffective connector contacts, or dead motor) For the diodes you do need to remove all the wiring sheath to get to them. But you should be able to test continuity from the connector to the motor contacts without removing the wiring (in one direction only due to the diode) before assessing that the diodes, the microswitch or the wiring is dead. Have you been able to see the broken power fold mirror working in the past? If yes how did it stop working? Suddenly and completely? |
Unfortunatly its never worked in the four or so years I've owned it. The drivers has always worked. It makes no sound or attempt to move at all. However it does operate the tilt mirror/heated mirrors correctly if that sheds any light?
This connector (which is shown in your post at the start). This inside the door? Which I guess involves removing the door card? |
The powerfold circuit (contact 1 and 7) is completely independent from any other function inside the mirror. So the fact that the rest is working does not tell anything about where the powerfold issue is.
If you have never seen it working, I am just wondering if your mirror frame would have been replaced at some point in time by a cheaper non power fold frame. The connector shown at the beginning of the post is behind the black plastic triangle on the inside of the door, at the bottom front corner of the window. This is also where is the only Torx screw that attaches the mirror to the door. The littlle plastic triangle needs to be pulled gently toward the back of the car (parallel to the glass), not toward the inside of the car, otherwise you will break the tiny tabs on the back. This is made more difficult by the fact that this plastic trim is glued. Use a blade to cut the glue before pulling. Yes the door card needs to be (at least partly according factory manual) removed. I find it more easy to just remove it completely. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:12 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands