Jaguar Forums - Jaguar Enthusiasts Forum

Jaguar Forums - Jaguar Enthusiasts Forum (https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/)
-   XJ XJ8 / XJR ( X308 ) (https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/xj-xj8-xjr-x308-27/)
-   -   Too much boost, too weak head gaskets (https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/xj-xj8-xjr-x308-27/too-much-boost-too-weak-head-gaskets-114539/)

andrew lowe 04-14-2014 11:47 AM


Originally Posted by XJR-99 (Post 954521)
It's combination of compression ratio, boost, ignition timing and used fuel.
Detonation is the enemy.

In theory, wouldn't the knock sensors/ ECU pull the timing to keep things in order ? Within reason obviously.

XJR-99 04-14-2014 12:22 PM

2 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by andrew lowe (Post 954528)
In theory, wouldn't the knock sensors/ ECU pull the timing to keep things in order ? Within reason obviously.

or..... :)

Brutal 04-14-2014 12:29 PM


Originally Posted by andrew lowe (Post 954528)
In theory, wouldn't the knock sensors/ ECU pull the timing to keep things in order ? Within reason obviously.

yes, but knock is a EVENT, not a prevention. Meaning yes once it SEES knock it retards timing. But really .2 increase is nothing and equal to carbon buildup on higher mileage engines

Hopefully not a next time, but as Water D already said. I would also stud the heads for those with the same issue. Stock bolts s t r e a c h(why theyre torque to yield) and the head lifts under increased cylinder pressure and there goes gasket seal. Studs clamp much better. And for those in this issue too but going back with stock bolts, at least replace them even though jag says reuse 2x's ok. Japanese automakers give a bolt streach spec to measure the threads and replace if exceeded. I have never seen this from Jag so I think better to replace with new at least.

XJR-99 04-14-2014 01:25 PM


Originally Posted by Brutal (Post 954560)
yes, but knock is a EVENT, not a prevention. Meaning yes once it SEES knock it retards timing. But really .2 increase is nothing and equal to carbon buildup on higher mileage engines

Hopefully not a next time, but as Water D already said. I would also stud the heads for those with the same issue. Stock bolts s t r e a c h(why theyre torque to yield) and the head lifts under increased cylinder pressure and there goes gasket seal. Studs clamp much better. And for those in this issue too but going back with stock bolts, at least replace them even though jag says reuse 2x's ok. Japanese automakers give a bolt streach spec to measure the threads and replace if exceeded. I have never seen this from Jag so I think better to replace with new at least.

It's a bit complex calculation what's the compression ratio when head in my case is totally 0.7mm ( 0.0275" ) lower than stock. Need to know volume of cylinder displacement, volume of clearance, dome of piston, volume of head gasket and volume of chamber.

Discussion about head bolts: https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/x...d-bolts-90344/

andrew lowe 04-15-2014 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by XJR-99 (Post 954552)
or..... :)

that'll do it. lol

Brutal 04-16-2014 04:49 PM

if Im building a performance engine. Ill clean and smooth chambers and then cc them with a burret to measure chamber volume and piston dome. Then unshroud valve if needed and match cc of each chambers AFTER valve job, decking. Piston dome is easy for flat or dished unless a + dome then measure 1" down in hole. there are many formulas for figuring compression ratio once you have bore, stroke, piston chamber volume etc and compressed gasket volume which is given my manufacture of most head gaskets. make a chamber cylinder cover out of 1/4" plexiglass and chamfer a hole in the top corner to get air out. seal against head with vasaline thin coat and I like to use which hazel or colored rubbing alcohol to see fluid.

Cambo 04-16-2014 05:24 PM

There was mention of ARP making custom head studs for the AJ-V8 HERE but he mentioned $1000 for a set, and 10 weeks lead time...ouch!

Brutal 04-16-2014 06:14 PM


Originally Posted by Cambo351 (Post 956159)
There was mention of ARP making custom head studs for the AJ-V8 HERE but he mentioned $1000 for a set, and 10 weeks lead time...ouch!

I spent about $400 something with them on the V6 Nissan. and talked to them gave dimensions needed and I dont think anything had to be custom. They just pulled pieces together and basically made a kit with what would work correctly

avos 04-17-2014 12:26 AM

Although I like the idea of the ARP bolts although I haven't had any issues yet on my engine (4.2 mls head gaskets), and I have been running 24 psi, although for a short while, most was between 20 and 23 psi. Don't know when it becomes a danger with the stretch bolts and 4.2 mls gaskets though (outside of detonations). The main reason I haven't used them is that you can't take off the heads anymore without lifting the engine.

With the 4.2 MLS gaskets (instead of the 4.0 Composite) you increase the compression about 3 points, not that much.

sparkenzap 04-17-2014 01:31 AM

I think it is hard to directly blame boost or even cylinders pressure increase due to added HP for that kind of failure. Isn't it almost certainly detonation?

avos 04-17-2014 01:57 AM


Originally Posted by sparkenzap (Post 956392)
I think it is hard to directly blame boost or even cylinders pressure increase due to added HP for that kind of failure. Isn't it almost certainly detonation?

There are a lot of stock 4.0 cars with headgasket failures (the composite ones, so pre 2001), and I don't know the causes for these, but would suggest indeed detonations as a main cause in combination with the weaker gaskets.

Am not sure if you will always be able to see traces of detonations, at least on my engine I was able to see them on my spark plugs when I was running the extreme high boost.

XJR-99 04-17-2014 04:07 AM

It's important to remember that head surface grinding increases the compression a bit . In my case, since it has been made twice, 2*0.1mm, so the ratio can be something like 9.3-9.5 at the moment. Not so low for quite high boosted engine. E85 would be good choice.

Anyway the engine runs very smoothly now. Thanks for full seat/valve job, new springs and careful valve measuring.

andrew lowe 04-17-2014 03:01 PM


Originally Posted by XJR-99 (Post 956457)
It's important to remember that head surface grinding increases the compression a bit . In my case, since it has been made twice, 2*0.1mm, so the ratio can be something like 9.3-9.5 at the moment. Not so low for quite high boosted engine. E85 would be good choice.

Anyway the engine runs very smoothly now. Thanks for full seat/valve job, new springs and careful valve measuring.

Can you run E85 in a nikasil engine? or is yours a steel replacement engine ?

JgaXkr 04-17-2014 05:58 PM


Originally Posted by XJR-99 (Post 956457)
It's important to remember that head surface grinding increases the compression a bit . In my case, since it has been made twice, 2*0.1mm, so the ratio can be something like 9.3-9.5 at the moment. Not so low for quite high boosted engine. E85 would be good choice.

Anyway the engine runs very smoothly now. Thanks for full seat/valve job, new springs and careful valve measuring.

What did you use for valve springs?

dc4prez 04-17-2014 08:29 PM

2 Attachment(s)
me too Sami -- I blew mine again, my own fault - 260KMH
But I was 4,000km from home, had to buy a car trailer and 4 wheel drive to get it home.
My problem was detonation, I need to fit a after market Piggy Back ECU

XJR-99 04-18-2014 02:19 AM


Originally Posted by dc4prez (Post 956982)
me too Sami -- I blew mine again, my own fault - 260KMH
But I was 4,000km from home, had to buy a car trailer and 4 wheel drive to get it home.
My problem was detonation, I need to fit a after market Piggy Back ECU

That's quite far away from home. I had just 85km on trailer. Did you blow your engine ( block or pistons ) or just head gaskets?

dc4prez 04-18-2014 06:48 AM

I pulled two plugs - 2 front right cyls again - plug electrodes smashed.
- I see compression ratio is being discussed.
it will always be swept volume over unswept volume.
the 0.2mm decking represents 0.295cc of unswept volume
I am going to look for a 4.2 litre block - I will speak with the "Big A" soon
Do you know of anyone who has had success using a piggy back ECU, you mentioned Viper on email somewhere, Local Jag dealer recommended Autronic s4 -
I would like to speak with someone who has fitted one

XJR-99 04-18-2014 08:56 AM


Originally Posted by dc4prez (Post 957154)
I pulled two plugs - 2 front right cyls again - plug electrodes smashed.
- I see compression ratio is being discussed.
it will always be swept volume over unswept volume.
the 0.2mm decking represents 0.295cc of unswept volume
I am going to look for a 4.2 litre block - I will speak with the "Big A" soon
Do you know of anyone who has had success using a piggy back ECU, you mentioned Viper on email somewhere, Local Jag dealer recommended Autronic s4 -
I would like to speak with someone who has fitted one

I will PM to you.

plums 04-18-2014 03:21 PM

Since it is a fuel sytem with a return circuit on a regulator, how about a rising rate fuel pressure regulator?

XJR-99 04-19-2014 03:25 AM


Originally Posted by plums (Post 957440)
Since it is a fuel sytem with a return circuit on a regulator, how about a rising rate fuel pressure regulator?

We have changed to such a regulator type.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:24 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands