2014XK-R or 2013 MB 550SL?
Looking at a CPO 2013 Sl550 or a new 2014 Jaguar XK-R. I like the performance and reliability of the MB but would also like to try a supercharged Jag before I die. I think that Jag reliability has become better though I have read some reports that there still might be hiccups. Also I bet that resale will be weaker on the Jag.
I know there might be a slant on here but there also might be people that have looked at both. Opinions? |
I have had both brands- Mercedes has the edge on longevity and prestige, but Merc can't touch a Jag in terms of panache and overall feel.
|
Looks like you are in the wrong forum for the X150 XKR, but why not have one of each.
I may buy one of each, but not for another 10 years or so. |
Originally Posted by Mulepick
(Post 1158273)
Looking at a CPO 2013 Sl550 or a new 2014 Jaguar XK-R. ..........
I've moved your question from XK8/XKR 1997-2006 to XK/XKR 2006 onwards forum. Members here with the model you are considering will certainly have opinions! Graham |
Have you driven both?
|
Originally Posted by GGG
(Post 1158616)
Welcome to the forum Mulepick,
I've moved your question from XK8/XKR 1997-2006 to XK/XKR 2006 onwards forum. Members here with the model you are considering will certainly have opinions! Graham |
Mercedes - park it next to the other one... They can look nice in the right colors, but they don't do much for me. I am not convinced they will last longer or be less expensive to own once the warranty is over.
|
I have a 2013 SLK55 AMG and a 2013 XKR. I have no loyalty to brand, but IMO the Jaguar is the better car. Why? Much better performance, just as reliable or more so, and looks so good.
|
I'm strong jaguar fan as can be seen in the list below. I have also owned Mercedes. regarding reliability they are about the same. Once you have driven a Jaguar for an extended period of time you get hooked. Why? There is no other car on the market that feels and drives like a Jaguar, it supple, luxurious and has a distinctive style all its own.
My suggestion; if you can find rental cars similar to what you are looking for rent each one for a day or two and then make your decision. You won't be sorry with either, but, as said before the Jaguar is very special. |
After properly driving them both (as I did) ask yourself which one:
Gave you the bigger grin Drove like a dream Sounded like automotive Nirvana Made you want to climb right back in Continues to draw your gaze longer And made you post on the Jaguar forum... I think you know the answer... Welcome to the Club! |
Jag is an experience and Mercedes is an appliance. You really need to get into the AMG range to compare but even then... it will never be as special.
|
Woopy Doo!!! Another Mercedes Benz on the road. GET REAL... Get the Jaguar and watch how you turn into a ROCK STAR overnight!! ;)
Loth |
Originally Posted by Lothar52
(Post 1159273)
Woopy Doo!!! Another Mercedes Benz on the road. GET REAL... Get the Jaguar and watch how you turn into a ROCK STAR overnight!! ;)
Loth |
As a recovering Mercedes owner, and a long-time Jaguar owner I can say that the quality of modern Jaguars is easily as good - no wait,... much better than the quality of Mercedes (or BMW or Audi...); the Jaguars have more style, are more luxurious, are more exclusive, make you smile, increase your testosterone level, easily get you speeding tickets...and when you park a Jaguar you ALWAYS, always turn back to look at it. 'nuff said.
|
Originally Posted by sov211
(Post 1160341)
As a recovering Mercedes owner, and a long-time Jaguar owner I can say that the quality of modern Jaguars is easily as good - no wait,... much better than the quality of Mercedes (or BMW or Audi...); the Jaguars have more style, are more luxurious, are more exclusive, make you smile, increase your testosterone level, easily get you speeding tickets...and when you park a Jaguar you ALWAYS, always turn back to look at it. 'nuff said.
|
The Benzes are a dime a dozen. Well, maybe not a dime, but you get the point. I've owned both, myself, although my Benz model was not the one you are considering. It was a V8 E class, though. Nice car. Rock solid.
The 5 liter XKR is a great car. Not very many on the road. Gorgeous and fast. Mine has been rock solid as well. |
I have a 2013 SL550 and the 2013 XKR coupe. Although both are great cars, I love the Jaguar XKR. As many have already stated, resale is better on the SL, but you should never buy a car for the resale value. You buy it because you enjoy driving it. Good luck.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:28 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands