The Folly of the Temperature Gauge
#41
If anyone has a speedometer cluster, I will still need that also.
Last edited by WhiteXKR; 11-01-2011 at 11:50 AM.
#42
#43
idea suggestion
Wow this is a hot topic (pardon the pun !!!!) I was just out for one of my last cruises until the salt hits the road for another long winter. Just an idea. The outside temp sensor, not sure where it is but it would be interesting to see what the range is of this. I personally would rather know my coolant temp etc than the outside air temp. Its 5 deg c today by the way. If this sensor does not have the range it may be possible to get one that does and tape or clamp it to the rad hose or something like that. Then all you would have to do is press and hold the external temp button and voila temp displayed in the car. May be possible and may be impossible but may be worth investigating.
#44
Wow this is a hot topic (pardon the pun !!!!) I was just out for one of my last cruises until the salt hits the road for another long winter. Just an idea. The outside temp sensor, not sure where it is but it would be interesting to see what the range is of this. I personally would rather know my coolant temp etc than the outside air temp. Its 5 deg c today by the way. If this sensor does not have the range it may be possible to get one that does and tape or clamp it to the rad hose or something like that. Then all you would have to do is press and hold the external temp button and voila temp displayed in the car. May be possible and may be impossible but may be worth investigating.
#45
The AOT sensor has nothing to do with the MAF - it's a completely separate item fixed right at the front of the car, installed on the light/horn loom.
I think it's a brilliant idea to use this sensor instead of attempting to re-calibrate the engine temp display. Lateral thinking at it's best from hdsg!
I think it's a brilliant idea to use this sensor instead of attempting to re-calibrate the engine temp display. Lateral thinking at it's best from hdsg!
#46
#47
#48
I'm looking at another approach to the problem. I've got an XKR, but have got hold of the 3 Gauge cluster and center veneer panel (can't stand the GPS). But then, realizing how 'useful' the gauges were, I began to wonder if I could do better.
My current plan (plan to work on this over Xmas as I have three weeks vacation to use) is to use a PLX DM200 as one gauge, and Arduino(s) driving OLED displays (matching style) in the other two (I think all three gauges need to 'digital' OR 'old school analog' - a mix doesn't work
This gives touch screen (on the arduinos), and a 'Jaguar' themed set of clocks, as well as OBD readouts, DTC codes and even reset. It's really a basic Car PC with 3 round screens, rather than single rectangular one.
Parts are ordered, but (as we all know) only time will tell how successful this is...though none of it is rocket science; it's really just bringing together bits and pieces of other projects. Won't be starting in earnest on this for a few weeks, but I'll be sure to keep everyone updated if there's interest in this approach.
I have done the first (and easiest) part - my default gauge background....
Edit: Just came to me. If WhiteXKR has worked out the signals to drive the stepper motors, we could perhaps use an Arduino (small, inexpensive embedded computer) to read the OBD (which I was planning on doing to drive the digital gauges and display a clock) and then drive the stepper motor. I'm already looking a the ODBD->Arduino end, this is just a different kind of output (to the original gauges).
-Steve
My current plan (plan to work on this over Xmas as I have three weeks vacation to use) is to use a PLX DM200 as one gauge, and Arduino(s) driving OLED displays (matching style) in the other two (I think all three gauges need to 'digital' OR 'old school analog' - a mix doesn't work
This gives touch screen (on the arduinos), and a 'Jaguar' themed set of clocks, as well as OBD readouts, DTC codes and even reset. It's really a basic Car PC with 3 round screens, rather than single rectangular one.
Parts are ordered, but (as we all know) only time will tell how successful this is...though none of it is rocket science; it's really just bringing together bits and pieces of other projects. Won't be starting in earnest on this for a few weeks, but I'll be sure to keep everyone updated if there's interest in this approach.
I have done the first (and easiest) part - my default gauge background....
Edit: Just came to me. If WhiteXKR has worked out the signals to drive the stepper motors, we could perhaps use an Arduino (small, inexpensive embedded computer) to read the OBD (which I was planning on doing to drive the digital gauges and display a clock) and then drive the stepper motor. I'm already looking a the ODBD->Arduino end, this is just a different kind of output (to the original gauges).
-Steve
Last edited by thefixer; 11-03-2011 at 07:00 AM.
#49
I'm looking at another approach to the problem. I've got an XKR, but have got hold of the 3 Gauge cluster and center veneer panel (can't stand the GPS). But then, realizing how 'useful' the gauges were, I began to wonder if I could do better.
My current plan (plan to work on this over Xmas as I have three weeks vacation to use) is to use a PLX DM200 as one gauge, and Arduino(s) driving OLED displays (matching style) in the other two (I think all three gauges need to 'digital' OR 'old school analog' - a mix doesn't work
This gives touch screen (on the arduinos), and a 'Jaguar' themed set of clocks, as well as OBD readouts, DTC codes and even reset. It's really a basic Car PC with 3 round screens, rather than single rectangular one.
Parts are ordered, but (as we all know) only time will tell how successful this is...though none of it is rocket science; it's really just bringing together bits and pieces of other projects. Won't be starting in earnest on this for a few weeks, but I'll be sure to keep everyone updated if there's interest in this approach.
I have done the first (and easiest) part - my default gauge background....
Edit: Just came to me. If WhiteXKR has worked out the signals to drive the stepper motors, we could perhaps use an Arduino (small, inexpensive embedded computer) to read the OBD (which I was planning on doing to drive the digital gauges and display a clock) and then drive the stepper motor. I'm already looking a the ODBD->Arduino end, this is just a different kind of output (to the original gauges).
-Steve
My current plan (plan to work on this over Xmas as I have three weeks vacation to use) is to use a PLX DM200 as one gauge, and Arduino(s) driving OLED displays (matching style) in the other two (I think all three gauges need to 'digital' OR 'old school analog' - a mix doesn't work
This gives touch screen (on the arduinos), and a 'Jaguar' themed set of clocks, as well as OBD readouts, DTC codes and even reset. It's really a basic Car PC with 3 round screens, rather than single rectangular one.
Parts are ordered, but (as we all know) only time will tell how successful this is...though none of it is rocket science; it's really just bringing together bits and pieces of other projects. Won't be starting in earnest on this for a few weeks, but I'll be sure to keep everyone updated if there's interest in this approach.
I have done the first (and easiest) part - my default gauge background....
Edit: Just came to me. If WhiteXKR has worked out the signals to drive the stepper motors, we could perhaps use an Arduino (small, inexpensive embedded computer) to read the OBD (which I was planning on doing to drive the digital gauges and display a clock) and then drive the stepper motor. I'm already looking a the ODBD->Arduino end, this is just a different kind of output (to the original gauges).
-Steve
I definitely would be interested in talking if you implement Arduino code to read OBDII.
Unfortunately though, OBDII (or the vehicle itself) does not have access to oil pressure data, other than a low pressure switch, so that needs to be an added sensor and analog.
#50
I'll definitely keep you updated; I'm keeping my fingers crossed that nothing comes along to interrupt my 'play time' next month....
-Steve
#51
Update on progress....I decided I couldn't wait until vacation time to start playing, and have had some success....
I have the Arduino up and running with a small LCD display, showing a very basic analog and digital clocks (this LCD is really too small for the final gauge, but is good as a test)
I've also (just) got the Arduino talking to the OBD system on my Ford Ranger (testing on that first, as it's a lot less $$$ if I blow something up). At the moment I'm just pumping the data over another serial port to the PC and showing it there as ascii, but the two tests combined mean I can grab data from OBD and display graphically....this could work...
-Steve
I have the Arduino up and running with a small LCD display, showing a very basic analog and digital clocks (this LCD is really too small for the final gauge, but is good as a test)
I've also (just) got the Arduino talking to the OBD system on my Ford Ranger (testing on that first, as it's a lot less $$$ if I blow something up). At the moment I'm just pumping the data over another serial port to the PC and showing it there as ascii, but the two tests combined mean I can grab data from OBD and display graphically....this could work...
-Steve
#52
#53
The present guage is nothing more than an idiot light. It did save my bacon once when I overheated. If you change to an actual analog sending unit with a calibrated guage, the next problem is to realize that the location of the sending unit does not provide a representitive sample of the overall engine temperature. Where are you going to relocate the sending unit? Maybe you will acutally need two or three wired in parrallel. Or, maybe a little program could give readings from each sender at five second intervals...... Just accept the idiot light. It works.
#54
The present guage is nothing more than an idiot light. It did save my bacon once when I overheated. If you change to an actual analog sending unit with a calibrated guage, the next problem is to realize that the location of the sending unit does not provide a representitive sample of the overall engine temperature. Where are you going to relocate the sending unit? Maybe you will acutally need two or three wired in parrallel. Or, maybe a little program could give readings from each sender at five second intervals...... Just accept the idiot light. It works.
Last edited by WhiteXKR; 11-12-2011 at 11:48 AM.
#55
There's something here I don't quite understand. As the car is warming up the temperature gauge acts like, well, a gauge. It creeps up to mid-range as we would expect.
So is the idea that above mid-range it becomes an idiot-light ... that it won't move above mid-range until temperatures are way above normal?
I've never had an overheat on this car, so no first-hand experience.
So is the idea that above mid-range it becomes an idiot-light ... that it won't move above mid-range until temperatures are way above normal?
I've never had an overheat on this car, so no first-hand experience.
#56
There's something here I don't quite understand. As the car is warming up the temperature gauge acts like, well, a gauge. It creeps up to mid-range as we would expect.
So is the idea that above mid-range it becomes an idiot-light ... that it won't move above mid-range until temperatures are way above normal?
I've never had an overheat on this car, so no first-hand experience.
So is the idea that above mid-range it becomes an idiot-light ... that it won't move above mid-range until temperatures are way above normal?
I've never had an overheat on this car, so no first-hand experience.
#57
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,743
Received 10,757 Likes
on
7,101 Posts
There's something here I don't quite understand. As the car is warming up the temperature gauge acts like, well, a gauge. It creeps up to mid-range as we would expect.
So is the idea that above mid-range it becomes an idiot-light ... that it won't move above mid-range until temperatures are way above normal?
So is the idea that above mid-range it becomes an idiot-light ... that it won't move above mid-range until temperatures are way above normal?
Without re-reading every post I think it's be concluded that you'll see a fixed reading from 180ºF to 230ºF. I don't think anyone has determined what the needle does once the temp goes higher. I presume it then behaves like a normal gauge again....as it does from ambient to 180ºF.
IOW, at 231ºF I don't think the needle suddenly bounces all the way over to the hot end of the scale.
Cheers
DD
#58
I remember when I bought a 10 year old X300 Soverign, Having Totaled one that was 2 years younger.
The Totaled one had the plasibo gauges, so I was used to them.
I picked up my older car, which being an early car had the gauges operating properly, drove 100 motorway miles, then as I pulled off and was stationarry at the lights noticed preasure in the red and an increasing temp.
My Jag specialist had to calm me down whilst explaining all was well and this is why Jaguar put doctored gauges in.
Regards
The Totaled one had the plasibo gauges, so I was used to them.
I picked up my older car, which being an early car had the gauges operating properly, drove 100 motorway miles, then as I pulled off and was stationarry at the lights noticed preasure in the red and an increasing temp.
My Jag specialist had to calm me down whilst explaining all was well and this is why Jaguar put doctored gauges in.
Regards
#59
The answer to my question was in the first post in this thread ... in the form of a graph no less. RTFM.
But I wonder if maybe there's some justification for what they did here. In the range up to ~ 230 deg. F. the pressure in the system should be well within limits ... no more than 10 PSI or so. Much hotter than that and trouble could be coming.
So maybe for most drivers showing 180 - 230 deg. as "normal" is not such a bad idea. They probably had something like this in mind.
Last edited by Dennis07; 11-12-2011 at 03:46 PM.
#60
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,743
Received 10,757 Likes
on
7,101 Posts
I believe the author of the first post mentioned that he had no data as to what happens beyond the midway point of the gauge and/or beyond 230ºF. I think that area of the graph is speculation but probably correct. That is, conventional operation on both ends of a wide dead zone.
Yes, there is a certain logic to the arrangement if it works at the "hot end" the way I'm thinking it works.
Cheers
DD
Yes, there is a certain logic to the arrangement if it works at the "hot end" the way I'm thinking it works.
Cheers
DD