Sports Cars: Chevrolet Corvette, Jaguar F-Type, Porsche Boxter, Porsche Cayman

Premium Sports Cars: Jaguar F-Type R, Porsche 911, Porsche 911 Turbo/Turbo S

Performance Sports Coupes/Convertibles: BMW M4

2015 Editors' Choice for Best Cars, Trucks, Crossovers, SUVs, and Hybrids ? Car and Driver

 

Looks like the first page was just a sampling. The rankings are actually once you click deeper in. The F-type ranks 4th in both categories.

Sports Cars:
1st: Stingray
2nd: Cayman
3rd: Boxster
4th: F-type
5th: Alfa 4C
6th: Nissan Z
7th: SLK
8th: TT/TTS

Premium Sports Cars:
1st: 911
2nd: AMG GT
3rd: R8
4th: F-type R
5th: GTR
6th: SLK55
7th: Evora
8th: Viper SRT
9th: GranTurismo

 

The fact that the F-types finished high on the lists is not surprising. BUT,
the Nissan Z, finishing 6th is stunning. Haven't heard a word about the 370Z and its merits in several years, and this is certainly not a new platform.

 

Are you sure those are the rankings? The AMG GT isn't out yet, how can it be ranked or compared?

 

I don't claim to understand their reasoning or requirements but you can see the ranks right on the site and it definitely isn't a random order.

**Scroll down, it is below the initial overview section. Click "Rank in Premium Sports Cars" to view the entire list.
Jaguar F-type R Reviews - Jaguar F-type R Price, Photos, and Specs - CARandDRIVER