Ok, I am having ZERO luck getting any local folks in Cincy, OH area to call me back to set up a time to do an appraisal on my car. They don't return calls, emails for days, then when they do we can't can get schedules to work to get it done then it is weeks again before they get back with me.
Is there online stuff like Hagerty or the like that I can use? How would they appraise my car if they don't see it? Any suggestions?

 

Try Hagerty insurance. They're an agreed value company that's easy and pleasant to work with, have knowledgable folks, no irritating agents, they send you worthwhile magazines and they pay claims. Look them up on the internet. For older stuff they're great.
Tad Brenner
1997 XK8
1954 Mercedes 300sl and 1957 220s
Lots of old Brit bikes (they insure those too)

 

AMPAC does all mine, no mileage restrictions and agreed value, love them

 

I use Hagerty and they wanted to know how much I paid and what I think it's worth. They did not ask for an appraisal of either car. I second Vincentbrough's comments.