Fuel Cat- Legit or No?
#1
Fuel Cat- Legit or No?
I see this in-line device posted on Ebay and various other adverts called, the "Fuel Cat". Supposedly improves MPG, More Power, Better Emissions, stops stale fuel etc, when joined into the XJ-40 Fuel Rail..... Any thoughts, experience with this device?
Jag Bro 91' Sovereign
Jag Bro 91' Sovereign
#2
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Crossroads of America
Posts: 19,392
Received 12,738 Likes
on
6,380 Posts
I remember this being mentioned on the Jag-Lovers forum many years ago. The Fuel Cat website sure makes it seem like magic:
What is Fuel Cat? - Fuel Cat - Improving fuel efficiency
I don't see any mention of a patent.... Which makes me wonder, if this technology is so effective, why aren't all of the automakers including "fuel catalyst" units in their new vehicles? Or perhaps more logically, why haven't CARB and the EPA insisted on it?
Hope to hear from someone who has tried one!
Cheers,
Don
What is Fuel Cat? - Fuel Cat - Improving fuel efficiency
I don't see any mention of a patent.... Which makes me wonder, if this technology is so effective, why aren't all of the automakers including "fuel catalyst" units in their new vehicles? Or perhaps more logically, why haven't CARB and the EPA insisted on it?
Hope to hear from someone who has tried one!
Cheers,
Don
#3
At the bottom of this post is a link to an article by a man who seems rather educated on the fuel systems of Internal Combustion Engines. He decries Fuel Cat as a scam for technical reasons in contrast to their claims. He could be just a hater, but at this point I will stay clear of this thing until I hear from someone 1st hand who's used one on any car especially an XJ40. WARNING: This guys vernacular is quite crude and "out there".
Also the Office of Fair Trade (In the UK I suppose?), issued basically a type of Cease and Desist Order to the manufacturers of Fuel Cat many years ago in this link.... so yea. 2000
Fuel Cat and Techstore.co.uk - Scam Warning
So.. Never Mind
Also the Office of Fair Trade (In the UK I suppose?), issued basically a type of Cease and Desist Order to the manufacturers of Fuel Cat many years ago in this link.... so yea. 2000
Fuel Cat and Techstore.co.uk - Scam Warning
So.. Never Mind
The following users liked this post:
Don B (04-19-2017)
#4
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,255 Likes
on
1,840 Posts
There were similar devices sold on this side of the pond years ago, each of which promised miracles but delivered none.
Sounds like this company spends more time and money trying to evade the office of fair trade than they do in proving that their product works- which of course cannot be done as this would defying several laws of physics and would involve alchemy.
The OEMs each spend millions of dollars each year trying to squeeze more efficiency out of their products. 1/10th of a MPG gain is considered a major victory. If this bolt on device can provide 2-5 mpg as some 'happy customers' claim, why do the OEMs not use the technology as well?
Sounds like this company spends more time and money trying to evade the office of fair trade than they do in proving that their product works- which of course cannot be done as this would defying several laws of physics and would involve alchemy.
The OEMs each spend millions of dollars each year trying to squeeze more efficiency out of their products. 1/10th of a MPG gain is considered a major victory. If this bolt on device can provide 2-5 mpg as some 'happy customers' claim, why do the OEMs not use the technology as well?
The following users liked this post:
Don B (04-19-2017)
#5
I read both the "pro" and the "anti" articles.
One of the maker's claims was that the device promoted more "complete" burning and increased the octane rating - enabling the engine to use a lower octane rating fuel.
Ordinarily, increasing the octane rating REDUCES fuel volatility, so I'm not sure how a device purported to increase fuel volatility could accomplish that, but there again, it is a "miracle" device .....
Larry
One of the maker's claims was that the device promoted more "complete" burning and increased the octane rating - enabling the engine to use a lower octane rating fuel.
Ordinarily, increasing the octane rating REDUCES fuel volatility, so I'm not sure how a device purported to increase fuel volatility could accomplish that, but there again, it is a "miracle" device .....
Larry
The following users liked this post:
Don B (04-19-2017)
#6
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,255 Likes
on
1,840 Posts
#7
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,014
Received 1,410 Likes
on
876 Posts
Groundhog Day . . . April 1st again, and again, and again!
How can any device in a fuel rail or pressure line, do magic? I used to draw comfort that such "Hollywood" scams were banned in Australia, but I notice the re-emergence even here, of "Hiclone" - a similar anti-Physics, anti-commonsense device, previously banned in several States, now being "nudge-nudge, wink, wink" promoted once again.
Just my 2 cents,
Ken
How can any device in a fuel rail or pressure line, do magic? I used to draw comfort that such "Hollywood" scams were banned in Australia, but I notice the re-emergence even here, of "Hiclone" - a similar anti-Physics, anti-commonsense device, previously banned in several States, now being "nudge-nudge, wink, wink" promoted once again.
Just my 2 cents,
Ken