Tachometer Twitches and Engine Jolts at Idle
#1
Tachometer Twitches and Engine Jolts at Idle
Lately I've been noticing random slight twitches in the tach when waiting at the lights. Just small, about a needle's width. These are accompanied by a quick but definite jerk or jolt felt through the seat (both mine and the car's), and a small twitch to the left (lower) of the ammeter (or is it technically a voltmeter?), again barely half a needle's width.
It seems to do it more when the engine is warm, and lately I've noticed (as the weather warms??) that the revs tend more towards 600 rpm than 700 rpm at idle. So the twitch might be from 600 to 650, just for an instant.
Looking up tach twitches, I seem to get lots of stuff about major swings, but these are very minor in terms of how much the engine surges. Suggestions I've read cover everything from a failing coil to ECU issues to a dirty throttle body. (As an aside, I haven't found much in the forum about cleaning XJS throttle bodies. I took a look at mine, and there does appear to be a minor blackening discolouration around where the throttle rests at idle. So perhaps that's the first priority....)
As usual, any hints or suggestions will be most gratefully received.
It seems to do it more when the engine is warm, and lately I've noticed (as the weather warms??) that the revs tend more towards 600 rpm than 700 rpm at idle. So the twitch might be from 600 to 650, just for an instant.
Looking up tach twitches, I seem to get lots of stuff about major swings, but these are very minor in terms of how much the engine surges. Suggestions I've read cover everything from a failing coil to ECU issues to a dirty throttle body. (As an aside, I haven't found much in the forum about cleaning XJS throttle bodies. I took a look at mine, and there does appear to be a minor blackening discolouration around where the throttle rests at idle. So perhaps that's the first priority....)
As usual, any hints or suggestions will be most gratefully received.
#2
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,739
Received 10,749 Likes
on
7,100 Posts
I'd say you have a fault in your 'primary' ignition system. That is, the 12v side of the ignition. Not the high voltage output side to the spark plugs...known as the 'secondary' side.
Loose connection at the coil(s), failing ignition switch, ignition amp.module problem/poor connection....that sort of thing. The clue is the tach twitch coinciding with (what sounds like) a misfire. The tach takes its reading from the primary side of the ignition system
Cheers
DD
Loose connection at the coil(s), failing ignition switch, ignition amp.module problem/poor connection....that sort of thing. The clue is the tach twitch coinciding with (what sounds like) a misfire. The tach takes its reading from the primary side of the ignition system
Cheers
DD
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (05-24-2018)
#3
Thanks, Doug. Always helpful.
So the "primary" side is from the coils to the distributor, with the "secondary" side from there to the plugs?
Loose coil connections - I'll see if anything stands out. By "ignition switch," you don't mean the one I turn with the key, right? Where would I look for the ignition amp. module? If it's a connections issue, I might be able to fix that, so long as I knew where to look.
So the "primary" side is from the coils to the distributor, with the "secondary" side from there to the plugs?
Loose coil connections - I'll see if anything stands out. By "ignition switch," you don't mean the one I turn with the key, right? Where would I look for the ignition amp. module? If it's a connections issue, I might be able to fix that, so long as I knew where to look.
#4
Okay, I took a look at the coils. Being a facelift V12, there are two small coils nestled in the vee. The rear coil, with three wires coming out of the connector, appears normal. The front coil, with two wires coming out of the connector, is not normal.
I'm guessing the insulation shouldn't be peeling away like that....
I don't know if that could cause the issue, but a prompt fix seems in order. High-temperature insulation tape wrapped around the wire, or is that just a cowboy fix?
I'm guessing the insulation shouldn't be peeling away like that....
I don't know if that could cause the issue, but a prompt fix seems in order. High-temperature insulation tape wrapped around the wire, or is that just a cowboy fix?
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (05-24-2018)
#5
Hi Someday
If you can take the wire out of the Plug without cutting the wire, which 'may' be held in by a grub screw?
Then it would be better to 'get off your horse' and get some Shrink Wrap
These come in a kit of various sizes and just slide over the offending wire, where a bit of heat from a heat gun, will see the Shrink Wrap er...... Shrink! and pull itself tight on the wire
Not expensive to buy for just a few Yen
Maybe that bare wire was causing the problem (on occasions)
If you can take the wire out of the Plug without cutting the wire, which 'may' be held in by a grub screw?
Then it would be better to 'get off your horse' and get some Shrink Wrap
These come in a kit of various sizes and just slide over the offending wire, where a bit of heat from a heat gun, will see the Shrink Wrap er...... Shrink! and pull itself tight on the wire
Not expensive to buy for just a few Yen
Maybe that bare wire was causing the problem (on occasions)
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (05-24-2018)
#6
Thanks, pardner. I've read about shrink wrap stuff, and I think I've seen it in the shops. The heat gun will be harder. It'll require (a) a heat gun, and more crucially, (b) a power socket I can use. That will be harder to track down. Mind you, the heat in the vee may be all that's needed....
I think I might also try running the engine at night with the bonnet opening and seeing if anything looks sparkly down by that bare wire.
I think I might also try running the engine at night with the bonnet opening and seeing if anything looks sparkly down by that bare wire.
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (05-24-2018)
#7
Pro tem use some ordinary pvc electrical insulating tape. But this may be symptomatic of other loom wires cooking hard too.
I would follow Doug's advice and check all the non HT wires in the system. (ie the 12 volt primary side wires.
Also, there is stuff called self amalgamating tape which you could use, the silicone variety of which is heat resistant.
I would follow Doug's advice and check all the non HT wires in the system. (ie the 12 volt primary side wires.
Also, there is stuff called self amalgamating tape which you could use, the silicone variety of which is heat resistant.
The following 2 users liked this post by Greg in France:
orangeblossom (05-24-2018),
Some Day, Some Day (05-24-2018)
Trending Topics
#8
#9
I do investigate the visible wiring on a semi-regular basis, but hadn't spotted this fraying. But I only noticed the symptoms this month, so maybe it's new and I will definitely check the other wiring carefully. I'm not entirely sure which wires I should check, so will check all I can see....
#10
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (05-24-2018)
#11
Don't try this at Home! but I have even done the Shrink Wrap using a Cigarette Lighter
Fire Extinguisher handy just in case!
Also if you borrow her Hair Dryer without asking her permission, keep all sharp objects hidden away and Sleep with one eye open!
Ask me how I know!
#12
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Walnut Creek, California
Posts: 6,796
Received 2,399 Likes
on
1,880 Posts
Well, if the owner and car were not in Japan, but, stateside, I'd suggest Harbor Freight for the heat gun. I have one. It is great.
There are a couple of hair blow dry guns around. will work, nut just a tad short on heat.
When I did a ton of splice and older in converting my I6 to V8, I used book matches. OK.
I have a backup. A piezo ignition butane lighter for the fire place or BBQ.
And, there are mini torches. My son fancies those and says my stuff is antique and outdated...
Carl
There are a couple of hair blow dry guns around. will work, nut just a tad short on heat.
When I did a ton of splice and older in converting my I6 to V8, I used book matches. OK.
I have a backup. A piezo ignition butane lighter for the fire place or BBQ.
And, there are mini torches. My son fancies those and says my stuff is antique and outdated...
Carl
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (05-24-2018)
#13
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Walnut Creek, California
Posts: 6,796
Received 2,399 Likes
on
1,880 Posts
That tach is a great tattle tale. Ignition is off a bit.
And, oh yeah, that bare wire is "the smoking gun" A wiggle and the wire goes to ground and a momentary misfire takes place.
As Doug says, start the examination the primary power source. The ignition switch, yes the one that accepts the key to turn and fire the engine. That wire should go to the + post on the coil.
But, surely checking the wire from the + post to the distributor is also a good idea.
Carl
And, oh yeah, that bare wire is "the smoking gun" A wiggle and the wire goes to ground and a momentary misfire takes place.
As Doug says, start the examination the primary power source. The ignition switch, yes the one that accepts the key to turn and fire the engine. That wire should go to the + post on the coil.
But, surely checking the wire from the + post to the distributor is also a good idea.
Carl
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (05-24-2018)
#14
Hi Someday
You need some of these Shrink Wrap Tubes
Assorted Shrink Wrap Tubing
Lots of different sizes to fit almost any Wire
Slide the Tube over the Wire
Carefully Heat the Shrink Wrap Tube
The Shrink Wrap Tube holds really tight and almost any source of Heat will do but keep it away from anything inflammable
That Tube could have done with a bit more heat but I was also holding the Camera and taking the Photo which made it a bit 'Awks'
You need some of these Shrink Wrap Tubes
Assorted Shrink Wrap Tubing
Lots of different sizes to fit almost any Wire
Slide the Tube over the Wire
Carefully Heat the Shrink Wrap Tube
The Shrink Wrap Tube holds really tight and almost any source of Heat will do but keep it away from anything inflammable
That Tube could have done with a bit more heat but I was also holding the Camera and taking the Photo which made it a bit 'Awks'
Last edited by orangeblossom; 05-24-2018 at 04:13 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (05-24-2018)
#15
I think I'll try Greg's pro tem suggestion of PVC insulating tape to start with, and see if that fixes the issue. If so, I can look into more long-term solutions. If not, then the issue is presumably elsewhere. I haven't noticed any + or - markings on the coils, but will take a closer look, and check the other wires as much as I can.
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (05-24-2018)
#16
Well, I wrapped a but of insulating tape around the bare wire, and checked all the other wiring I could see, finding nothing obviously out of the norm, and this evening we took a drive down to Costco. Revs stayed steady at 700, or a hair under, and while there were the usual citations [vibrations! Bloody tablet...] which I still want to eliminate, the twitches and jolts were gone. So thanks to Doug and Greg for where to look and how to fix it, and everyone else for their advice.
Last edited by Some Day, Some Day; 05-25-2018 at 05:41 PM.
The following 3 users liked this post by Some Day, Some Day:
#17
SDSD
Well done. FWIW I would not be surprised if there is not a fracture/partial fracture in the copper part of the wire, and wrapping it up held the broken ends together better. It could have been shorting to the coil outer also, as that is very close and with bonnet shut it might have been pressing against it. Either way, good stuff.
Well done. FWIW I would not be surprised if there is not a fracture/partial fracture in the copper part of the wire, and wrapping it up held the broken ends together better. It could have been shorting to the coil outer also, as that is very close and with bonnet shut it might have been pressing against it. Either way, good stuff.
The following 2 users liked this post by Greg in France:
orangeblossom (05-25-2018),
Some Day, Some Day (05-25-2018)
#18
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,739
Received 10,749 Likes
on
7,100 Posts
Well, I wrapped a but of insulating tape around the bare wire, and checked all the other wiring I could see, finding nothing obviously out of the norm, and this evening we took a drive down to Costco. Revs stayed steady at 700, or a hair under, and while there were the usual citations which I still want to eliminate, the twitches and jolts were gone. So thanks to Doug and Greg for where to look and how to fix it, and everyone else for their advice.
Good work.
When working on the car for any reason always keep an eye peeled for similar wiring faults...as well as dirty, loose connectors and the like. I can all but promise they're lurking. Fix 'em as you find 'em!
Eradicate them, stomp them out, drive them back from the ramparts
And *whenever* you come across a ground point, clean it. Don't mull it over. Just do it
Cheers
DD
The following 3 users liked this post by Doug:
#19
Well, pretty much all the connectors are dirty, but as far as I can tell, that's the external plastic housing being mucky, and the connections themselves are well protected. Or I could be deluding myself. I don't want to start pulling on connectors without know exactly how to open them, however. Some of these are very firmly connected. I jiggled lots of wires and connectors, and didn't find any loose ones.
I did spot a couple of ground points, like on top of the radiator housing (at least I'm pretty sure that's what they are: several wires terminating in a nut). While pretty clean, it certainly wouldn't hurt to undo the nuts and give the metal a good scrub. I've got plenty of anhydrous ethanol, which should be okay. Also might get a toothbrush and use it on those mucky connector housings. I have a car show coming up, and it would be nice to have the engine bay looking somewhat clean....
I did spot a couple of ground points, like on top of the radiator housing (at least I'm pretty sure that's what they are: several wires terminating in a nut). While pretty clean, it certainly wouldn't hurt to undo the nuts and give the metal a good scrub. I've got plenty of anhydrous ethanol, which should be okay. Also might get a toothbrush and use it on those mucky connector housings. I have a car show coming up, and it would be nice to have the engine bay looking somewhat clean....
#20
I did spot a couple of ground points, like on top of the radiator housing (at least I'm pretty sure that's what they are: several wires terminating in a nut). While pretty clean, it certainly wouldn't hurt to undo the nuts and give the metal a good scrub. I've got plenty of anhydrous ethanol, which should be okay. Also might get a toothbrush and use it on those mucky connector housings. I have a car show coming up, and it would be nice to have the engine bay looking somewhat clean....
If the wires are black, they are grounds. I usually use a bit of fine steel wool to clean any corrosion off joints like that. A bit of dielectric grease on the now clean surfaces upon reassembly will keep any moisture out.
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (05-25-2018)