Need advice on used transfer case
#1
Need advice on used transfer case
Hi everyone,
I took my 2007 X-type to the mechanic because of an oil smell coming into the car that I couldn't identify the source of. They just told me that the transfer case is cracked and will need to be replaced...$4000 with labor and the part itself is $3000 (ouch).
When I asked them about putting in a used case, they said they would do it, but advised me up and down against doing that. I'm not sure if that is just mechanic propaganda, or if I should be worried about using a used part.
I am including a link to a transfer case I found on ebay that I am thinking of buying - 07 08 Jaguar x Type Transfer Case 225369 | eBay
Any advice on whether or not I should go this route would be extremely helpful.
Thanks!
James
I took my 2007 X-type to the mechanic because of an oil smell coming into the car that I couldn't identify the source of. They just told me that the transfer case is cracked and will need to be replaced...$4000 with labor and the part itself is $3000 (ouch).
When I asked them about putting in a used case, they said they would do it, but advised me up and down against doing that. I'm not sure if that is just mechanic propaganda, or if I should be worried about using a used part.
I am including a link to a transfer case I found on ebay that I am thinking of buying - 07 08 Jaguar x Type Transfer Case 225369 | eBay
Any advice on whether or not I should go this route would be extremely helpful.
Thanks!
James
#2
#3
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Great Mills, MD
Posts: 14,221
Likes: 0
Received 3,825 Likes
on
3,144 Posts
james, as many have found out, if you have recently had fluid added to the transfer case, it will cause a burning smell like you are experiencing. For that matter, if you have had the engine oil changed recently, that can cause what you are smelling (gotta love having the oil filter directly above the exhaust pipe).
As for a used transfer case, I say go for it. It is not any more risky than putting in a brand new one. If it is going to have issues, it is going to have issues.
The cracked transfer cases as I recall were mainly with the early X-Types. With the upgraded transfer case, this seems to have become a non-issue. Granted, if the mechanic is so "sure" that it is a cracked transfer case, then they should have no problem showing you the cracked case.
As for a used transfer case, I say go for it. It is not any more risky than putting in a brand new one. If it is going to have issues, it is going to have issues.
The cracked transfer cases as I recall were mainly with the early X-Types. With the upgraded transfer case, this seems to have become a non-issue. Granted, if the mechanic is so "sure" that it is a cracked transfer case, then they should have no problem showing you the cracked case.
#4
#5
#7
I also have a failed t- case in my 07 and is now getting a used replacement. Mine was not leaking fluid but began making a grinding noise 30K miles ago. Yesterday it finally locked up and is now toast. My Jag service rep said only used or remanufactured t-cases are available now. I think it's a crap-shoot whether the next one will be any good.
Trending Topics
#8
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Great Mills, MD
Posts: 14,221
Likes: 0
Received 3,825 Likes
on
3,144 Posts
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)