Popping Noise and Poor Idle when cold
#1
Popping Noise and Poor Idle when cold
I have a 2002, 2.5 X Type, 70,000 on the odometer. Earlier this fall it began to have the classic signs of intake gasket failure including rough idle and misfires when cold. I replaced the intake manifold gaskets as well as the two large o rings know as the EMT gaskets. I also througly checked for vacuum leaks included the brake booster lines and found no leaks. I also inspected the large vacuum hose that conducts the PVC flow and found no leaks. I did install clamps on the hose just to make sure it seals tight. After replacing the six upper intake manifold gaskets the problem disappeared however now that Winter has set in Minnesota and temps are consistently in the range -10 to -15 F nightly the problem has come back.
The car starts fine but refuses to fast idle as it should it struggles and pops at 400-500 rpms and eventually gets it's groove and runs good after about two minutes, if it doesn't kill. It sometimes kicks off codes like 300, 302, (misfires) It only behaves like this after sitting all night in the subzero cold it doesn't do it after it warmed up and cooled down during the day. ( I did replace the coolant temperature sensor ) PS, I did replace the plugs about 10k ago and the air filter as well and am using 5-30 oil.
Tonight, I am installing an engine heater to plug in overnight. Maybe these cars just cant handle the Global Warming, I have lived in Minnesota all long life and cant recollect many winters when the fierce cold came so early and has persisted without a respite.
Maybe these cars just are made for cold climates? The window washer portals on the hood constantly freeze up and have to freed up with hot water whilst someone hold the actuator button down.
Any thoughts or ideas would be greatly appreciated.
PS, Don't listen to anyone who says the World is warming: it's not!!! Believe what you see and experience not what you are told. We in the Central US are having record breaking cold for weeks at a time very early in the year.
The car starts fine but refuses to fast idle as it should it struggles and pops at 400-500 rpms and eventually gets it's groove and runs good after about two minutes, if it doesn't kill. It sometimes kicks off codes like 300, 302, (misfires) It only behaves like this after sitting all night in the subzero cold it doesn't do it after it warmed up and cooled down during the day. ( I did replace the coolant temperature sensor ) PS, I did replace the plugs about 10k ago and the air filter as well and am using 5-30 oil.
Tonight, I am installing an engine heater to plug in overnight. Maybe these cars just cant handle the Global Warming, I have lived in Minnesota all long life and cant recollect many winters when the fierce cold came so early and has persisted without a respite.
Maybe these cars just are made for cold climates? The window washer portals on the hood constantly freeze up and have to freed up with hot water whilst someone hold the actuator button down.
Any thoughts or ideas would be greatly appreciated.
PS, Don't listen to anyone who says the World is warming: it's not!!! Believe what you see and experience not what you are told. We in the Central US are having record breaking cold for weeks at a time very early in the year.
#2
I have a 2002, 2.5 X Type, 70,000 on the odometer. Earlier this fall it began to have the classic signs of intake gasket failure including rough idle and misfires when cold. I replaced the intake manifold gaskets as well as the two large o rings know as the EMT gaskets. I also througly checked for vacuum leaks included the brake booster lines and found no leaks. I also inspected the large vacuum hose that conducts the PVC flow and found no leaks. I did install clamps on the hose just to make sure it seals tight. After replacing the six upper intake manifold gaskets the problem disappeared however now that Winter has set in Minnesota and temps are consistently in the range -10 to -15 F nightly the problem has come back. The car starts fine but refuses to fast idle as it should it struggles and pops at 400-500 rpms and eventually gets it's groove and runs good after about two minutes, if it doesn't kill. It sometimes kicks off codes like 300, 302, (misfires) It only behaves like this after sitting all night in the subzero cold it doesn't do it after it warmed up and cooled down during the day. ( I did replace the coolant temperature sensor ) PS, I did replace the plugs about 10k ago and the air filter as well and am using 5-30 oil. Tonight, I am installing an engine heater to plug in overnight. Maybe these cars just cant handle the Global Warming, I have lived in Minnesota all long life and cant recollect many winters when the fierce cold came so early and has persisted without a respite. Maybe these cars just are made for cold climates? The window washer portals on the hood constantly freeze up and have to freed up with hot water whilst someone hold the actuator button down. Any thoughts or ideas would be greatly appreciated. PS, Don't listen to anyone who says the World is warming: it's not!!! Believe what you see and experience not what you are told. We in the Central US are having record breaking cold for weeks at a time very early in the year.
So far only thing I found was a bit of oil in my spark plug wells, cleaned that up but still seems to be happening..I'm thinking maybe the regulator isn't good?? That's with the alternator I believe..I replaced IMT o-rings, so running out of ideas.
Last edited by Noxparadise; 12-12-2013 at 08:58 PM.
#3
Simple physics may offer a clue.
I believe Richard Feynman (R.I.P.) may have a clue to the X-Type's various mysterious vaccuum related cold weather issues;
#5
Sounds like you both have some other issues going on, whether it is a vacuum leak, coils, plugs, throttle body,whatever, but it is certainly not normal. I have had my car over 5 years and never had anything like that happen in the winter. Maybe time to take it in to a trusted mechanic to get to the bottom of it.
Hope you can get to the bottom of it soon.
Hope you can get to the bottom of it soon.
The following users liked this post:
Stuart Beattie (01-31-2014)
#6
Sounds like you both have some other issues going on, whether it is a vacuum leak, coils, plugs, throttle body,whatever, but it is certainly not normal. I have had my car over 5 years and never had anything like that happen in the winter. Maybe time to take it in to a trusted mechanic to get to the bottom of it. Hope you can get to the bottom of it soon.
#7
rough idle
hey there im in florida and its starting to get nippy. my car was doing the same and sometimes it even threw the flashing check engine light. after getting tired of dealing with it i performed a full tune up, o-rings, coil packs plugs, airfilter and a serious deep cleaning of the throttle body. it now runs great and warms up just fine in the cold a.m.
The following users liked this post:
Stuart Beattie (01-31-2014)
Trending Topics
#8
Popping Noise and Poor Idle when cold
I have a 2002 x-type 3.0 , and I am having the same cold start issues. It is slowly getting worse over time. I am getting code errors of miss-fire. I have been watching the forum for some time and don't want to keep changing parts if I am not sure what to change.
After doing some trial and error testing on my own , I noticed that a few minutes of a hair dryer or small propane torch on the intake manifold to warm it just a few degree's , the car starts and runs much better for the real cold starts.
Are there any aftermarket Intake Manifold Gasket Sets that may work better than the OEM Gaskets ?
At this point I should change the spark plugs also, which plugs work the best for the 3.0 x-type ?
I thought it was time to share my experience since it seems there are a few people with 2002 x-types with the same issue of cold starts in the winter only. After the first start in the morning it is good all day even after a few hours of not running.
After doing some trial and error testing on my own , I noticed that a few minutes of a hair dryer or small propane torch on the intake manifold to warm it just a few degree's , the car starts and runs much better for the real cold starts.
Are there any aftermarket Intake Manifold Gasket Sets that may work better than the OEM Gaskets ?
At this point I should change the spark plugs also, which plugs work the best for the 3.0 x-type ?
I thought it was time to share my experience since it seems there are a few people with 2002 x-types with the same issue of cold starts in the winter only. After the first start in the morning it is good all day even after a few hours of not running.
#9
I have been going through the same issues all winter long.. Just this morning I had to start it, push the RPM's to 5000 and wait 45 seconds just to get my baby to idle!
Bear in mind these cars are cold-natured and were probably designed to be garage kept.
2003 X-Type with 157,000 miles.. Still running strong once warm.
Bear in mind these cars are cold-natured and were probably designed to be garage kept.
2003 X-Type with 157,000 miles.. Still running strong once warm.
#11
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: That Rectangular Hole in the Consciousness of America
Posts: 502
Received 132 Likes
on
91 Posts
I have a 2002 x-type 3.0 , and I am having the same cold start issues. It is slowly getting worse over time. I am getting code errors of miss-fire. I have been watching the forum for some time and don't want to keep changing parts if I am not sure what to change.
After doing some trial and error testing on my own , I noticed that a few minutes of a hair dryer or small propane torch on the intake manifold to warm it just a few degree's , the car starts and runs much better for the real cold starts.
Are there any aftermarket Intake Manifold Gasket Sets that may work better than the OEM Gaskets ?
At this point I should change the spark plugs also, which plugs work the best for the 3.0 x-type ?
I thought it was time to share my experience since it seems there are a few people with 2002 x-types with the same issue of cold starts in the winter only. After the first start in the morning it is good all day even after a few hours of not running.
After doing some trial and error testing on my own , I noticed that a few minutes of a hair dryer or small propane torch on the intake manifold to warm it just a few degree's , the car starts and runs much better for the real cold starts.
Are there any aftermarket Intake Manifold Gasket Sets that may work better than the OEM Gaskets ?
At this point I should change the spark plugs also, which plugs work the best for the 3.0 x-type ?
I thought it was time to share my experience since it seems there are a few people with 2002 x-types with the same issue of cold starts in the winter only. After the first start in the morning it is good all day even after a few hours of not running.
Problem will be solved.
(Use the plugs spec'd by Jaguar)
#12
A few minutes of heating the intake manifold a few degrees warmer solves my problem. (still not sure on the cause) I had the same issues as other people , when it was not to cold out, I could turn off and restart the car after 10 secs of rough idle and it would run perfect, real strange issue.(the computer must compensate for the air leak is my guess on the 2nd start)
If some of the other people out there having the same issue they could try heating there intake manifold alone before a cold start and post there starting results, that may be helpful for all of us with a cold start issue.
Thanks
#13
I have been going through the same issues all winter long.. Just this morning I had to start it, push the RPM's to 5000 and wait 45 seconds just to get my baby to idle!
Bear in mind these cars are cold-natured and were probably designed to be garage kept.
2003 X-Type with 157,000 miles.. Still running strong once warm.
Bear in mind these cars are cold-natured and were probably designed to be garage kept.
2003 X-Type with 157,000 miles.. Still running strong once warm.
The following users liked this post:
Stuart Beattie (01-31-2014)
#14
Join Date: Dec 2012
Location: Skipton, North Yorkshire, England
Posts: 2,542
Received 210 Likes
on
172 Posts
Hi Guys,
The washers will freeze with cheap screenwash, there are really good fluids out there and you can always cover the car in extreme weathers.
One neat trick I found was parking my car next to the kitchen or bathroom vents that discharge warm air alongside my meigbours house (on the drive), and I found I was the only person on the street who actually got up, got in the car and went to work in one foul swoop!!
Everybody else seemed to be rather busy
In times of seriously foul weather there is always the unknown, what I can see is that if you try to minimise the risks and seek advise there is plenty out there and people will in general be a lot happier AND SAFER!!!
Thanks Guys! Stu
The washers will freeze with cheap screenwash, there are really good fluids out there and you can always cover the car in extreme weathers.
One neat trick I found was parking my car next to the kitchen or bathroom vents that discharge warm air alongside my meigbours house (on the drive), and I found I was the only person on the street who actually got up, got in the car and went to work in one foul swoop!!
Everybody else seemed to be rather busy
In times of seriously foul weather there is always the unknown, what I can see is that if you try to minimise the risks and seek advise there is plenty out there and people will in general be a lot happier AND SAFER!!!
Thanks Guys! Stu
#15
Solved 2002 Jaguar x-type 3.0 rough idle on cold start.
Solved rough idle popping sounds on cold start. !!!!!
This problem came on real slow over years and slowly got worse.
it used to run rough at first cold start in the fall, Turn the car off and it would run perfect on the second start. That was with only running 10 seconds on the first start, so there was no chance for the motor to warm.
I was getting misfire codes and o2 sensor codes, I did not believe it was the plugs or the intake gaskets because the problem went away on the second start.
Slowing over time the problem did not go away on the 2nd start, and did not run good till the motor started to warm.
It got to the point I had to put the hair dryer on to warm the intake manifold to start the car without rough running. And I knew then it really was the intake manifold gaskets. The shops were recommending changing o2 sensors, and other sensors
I changed the upper and lower intake Manifold gaskets, and the plugs while I was in there, The old plugs looked nice a clean. So I am sure it was my gaskets leaking, not old plugs causing the problem, but did change plugs while I was in there.
Lots of posts of how to do the job on the forums.
I used Fel-Pro Ms96494, Fel-Pro MS96485 Autolite Double Platinum APP605
I did also replace the pcv valve when I was in there also. Nothing more.
I am proud to report the car starts and runs perfect at extreme cold temps, I am in Canada and you can trust me it is COLD LOL
Thanks to everyone for the help, I hope this helps other people.
This problem came on real slow over years and slowly got worse.
it used to run rough at first cold start in the fall, Turn the car off and it would run perfect on the second start. That was with only running 10 seconds on the first start, so there was no chance for the motor to warm.
I was getting misfire codes and o2 sensor codes, I did not believe it was the plugs or the intake gaskets because the problem went away on the second start.
Slowing over time the problem did not go away on the 2nd start, and did not run good till the motor started to warm.
It got to the point I had to put the hair dryer on to warm the intake manifold to start the car without rough running. And I knew then it really was the intake manifold gaskets. The shops were recommending changing o2 sensors, and other sensors
I changed the upper and lower intake Manifold gaskets, and the plugs while I was in there, The old plugs looked nice a clean. So I am sure it was my gaskets leaking, not old plugs causing the problem, but did change plugs while I was in there.
Lots of posts of how to do the job on the forums.
I used Fel-Pro Ms96494, Fel-Pro MS96485 Autolite Double Platinum APP605
I did also replace the pcv valve when I was in there also. Nothing more.
I am proud to report the car starts and runs perfect at extreme cold temps, I am in Canada and you can trust me it is COLD LOL
Thanks to everyone for the help, I hope this helps other people.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)