5.0 Timing Chain- New Information. Attn Techs
#41
I could be wrong and have been in the past but I would assume that Jaguar/LR handle their TSB or problems individually similar to other car manufacturers. I would have expected either a separate or join release TSB of the problem. I know that Toyota has a different release of TSB related issues then the Lexus division. Just my thoughts here.
#42
Hmmm, OK, thinking further: the ratchet not only maintains tension at startup when there's no oil pressure, it also maintains tension if the hydraulic element isn't working properly. So, a busted ratchet probably won't cause any harm by itself, but it does present a significant risk if there's a second failure within the tensioner.
Therefore, if you get the startup chatter, it would be a good idea to get the tensioner replaced. And when you do that, may as well replace the chains & guides too, since much of the effort is already expended in just getting to the tensioners.
Therefore, if you get the startup chatter, it would be a good idea to get the tensioner replaced. And when you do that, may as well replace the chains & guides too, since much of the effort is already expended in just getting to the tensioners.
1- timing chain tensioners, guides, and the chain itself (startup chatter)
2- all 4 actuators (potentially if constant tick at idle)
100% perfect now and this was the misery of my existence lol
Last edited by Lothar52; 03-28-2016 at 09:23 AM.
#43
I brought this subject up over a year ago & it was not taken seriously. The timing chain issue has been a known issue on the 5.0 engine for over 3 years. The original fix was to disassemble the front of the engine & replace the chains & tensioners. The later fix was to replace the tensioners with an updated version. This repair under warranty paid about 12 hours. We had a couple of cars that the chains were so stretched that with new tensioners fitted still made noise. This meant taking it apart again & install new chains as well. The issue was more common with Range Rover as there are far more of them on the road with the 5.0 compared to the Jaguars. The water pump issue was so common we were doing 3-4 a week. It is also a know issue with the 5.0. We would have cars towed in with the intake manifold melted because they had gotten so hot.
The frustration was epic... Thank God fixed under original Manu warranty.... My question is would a jaguar extended warranty cover it?! Considering it's not just cosmetic I'd certainly question the insurer if they would rather fix a chain or a damaged engine?!?
Last edited by Lothar52; 03-28-2016 at 09:18 AM.
#44
5.0 timing chain issues
Someone said Jaguar addressed this issue btw 2012 and 2013. Is that true and is there any documentation, or vin cutoff at which point newly designed parts were used in the builds? I would naturally like to confirm my 2013 XKR isn't going to spill it's guts all over the freeway. Vin: B49666, built between July 11 and 25 2012.
Thanks in advance for any info.
Thanks in advance for any info.
#47
#48
They do! My techs told me they fitted the last version of the chain and tensioners to my 12 XKR this last winter when all that was changed out. Still sounds like a brand new XKR with 36000 miles since that time!
#49
#50
My 5.0 has 80,000 miles and has had zero problems other than a water pump & coolant crossover tube. I change the oil every 7500 miles with jaguar Castrol oil. (Buy it at the dealer for $9.00 quart and change it myself).
When a timing chain stretches, the cam chain sprockets are usually worn too. So putting a new chain on worn sprockets will result in a shorter timing chain life. So you need to inspect the teeth profiles on the sprockets and look for wear. You should also replace the timing chain plastic chain guides. More expensive in parts, but labor is the major cost of replacing a timing chain.
When a timing chain stretches, the cam chain sprockets are usually worn too. So putting a new chain on worn sprockets will result in a shorter timing chain life. So you need to inspect the teeth profiles on the sprockets and look for wear. You should also replace the timing chain plastic chain guides. More expensive in parts, but labor is the major cost of replacing a timing chain.
#51
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: Naperville, Illinois USA
Posts: 4,571
Received 1,894 Likes
on
1,285 Posts
#54
#55
Mine has the tick or "sewing machine" sound but I thought it had to do with the DI, now I'm concerned that it is T/C & tensioners! I have not noticed any performance related or code issues yet but do see that fuel enconomy number is getting lower. Unfortunate for me though, warranty has long since passed so I'm on my own with this.
I'm not concerned with digging into a front end rebuild but wonder if anyone has attempted chain and tensioner replacement DIY? If so, perhaps they could post photos or pointers on what to watch for in the effort.
I would anticipate that while digging into the the front end I'd change the water pump to the latest version (if not already there) just to have that out of the way too.
I'm not concerned with digging into a front end rebuild but wonder if anyone has attempted chain and tensioner replacement DIY? If so, perhaps they could post photos or pointers on what to watch for in the effort.
I would anticipate that while digging into the the front end I'd change the water pump to the latest version (if not already there) just to have that out of the way too.
#56
Motoring through the web on this subject, it appears that the timing chains themselves to not wear/stretch abnormally.
My own experience is with motorcycle chain wear. As motorcycle chains wear, the link connecting pins (sic) themselves seem to wear from lack of internal lubrication and "thin", thus causing chain "stretch" or materially lengthen. The actual metal does not itself "stretch." A lengthened chain does not quite "fit" the drive sprockets, causing wear to the sprockets, which is evidenced by subtle tooth narrowing. The usual "test" for excessive motorcycle chain wear it to try to lift the chain from the sprocket teeth with one's fingers. If the chain is "snug", then it is probably not worn.
My own experience is with motorcycle chain wear. As motorcycle chains wear, the link connecting pins (sic) themselves seem to wear from lack of internal lubrication and "thin", thus causing chain "stretch" or materially lengthen. The actual metal does not itself "stretch." A lengthened chain does not quite "fit" the drive sprockets, causing wear to the sprockets, which is evidenced by subtle tooth narrowing. The usual "test" for excessive motorcycle chain wear it to try to lift the chain from the sprocket teeth with one's fingers. If the chain is "snug", then it is probably not worn.
#57
The guys who got to the problem stage had far more pronounced sounds.
If you remember the engine flush and injector cleaning trick, do that it cannot hurt.
This time there is something more aggressive available, CRC (1-tank) run 3 bottles, just keep an eye on the oil level. Or simply remove 1/2 quart before starting.
Then lubegard engine flush- I use this on every oil change anyway, gets every last bit of sludge out. (essentially breaks down oil) cant believe this is not widely know. However, now there are 6 brands offering the same thing, including Ravenol, so I suppose it is gaining popularity.
What's the service story on your car, was the oil changed at dealership by previous owner? It may hold some clue, the chain does not wear that bad with the prescribed oil nor do the tensioners get clogged with soot sludge. Which I believe wholeheartedly to be the only thing that can possibly fail with them. A member here pointed out that the teeth on ratchet mechanism can wear, yes, but at 20,000 miles?
One of these days we can meet in Atlanta or thereabouts and compare sounds. I go there once a year. (p.s. got any need for darkroom equip and supplies, giving it up sadly)
The following users liked this post:
George05 (10-16-2019)
#58
Thanks Q&C. After a bit more research I'm realizing I probably was just having a senior moment and the sounds I was imagining in this thread is not what I have encountered. (BTW, the wife says she thinks my mileage is because of my foot) Chain and tensioner failure sounds are unually less repetitive than what I'm hearing and more like thumps or cold knocks. So I think you are correct and not a worry in my case. I remember the Ford 4.6 encountered a campaign over failing tensioners caused by a supplier issue but that was well before this Jag engine era. You would think I'd remember what the sounds were from those failures, thus my senior moment!
I followed your suggestion earlier using Lubegard and now ensure I use prescribed engine oil. I wish I could be sure the PO followed that program but that just remains a question in my mind.
Better than an ATL meet would be to take the drive up NE GA for some curved road touring! Wish I could help with the equipment but I jumped to digital many moons ago and have since unloaded the messy stuff myself. I love to see fellow shutter enthusiasts work, if you get a chance send me a PM with some of yours!
I followed your suggestion earlier using Lubegard and now ensure I use prescribed engine oil. I wish I could be sure the PO followed that program but that just remains a question in my mind.
Better than an ATL meet would be to take the drive up NE GA for some curved road touring! Wish I could help with the equipment but I jumped to digital many moons ago and have since unloaded the messy stuff myself. I love to see fellow shutter enthusiasts work, if you get a chance send me a PM with some of yours!
#59
Hi,
After a bit more looking it is the VVT solenoids on the front of the motor i was thinking about, they are very simple to replace but does anyone know of a way to test these before replacing them?
My motor is pretty quiet at cold start-up with no rattle but once its warm (after 30 seconds or so of running) it makes a right racket. Jaguar have just quoted me £5,000 to fix so would like to investigate the easy(ier!) stuff first.
Edit...
I have just whipped them out and all 4 behave in the same way, apply 12v across the terminals and teh plunger comes out, can push it back inwith your finger even with 12v applied but is reasonably stiff.
looks like tensioners.....ouch.
After a bit more looking it is the VVT solenoids on the front of the motor i was thinking about, they are very simple to replace but does anyone know of a way to test these before replacing them?
My motor is pretty quiet at cold start-up with no rattle but once its warm (after 30 seconds or so of running) it makes a right racket. Jaguar have just quoted me £5,000 to fix so would like to investigate the easy(ier!) stuff first.
Edit...
I have just whipped them out and all 4 behave in the same way, apply 12v across the terminals and teh plunger comes out, can push it back inwith your finger even with 12v applied but is reasonably stiff.
looks like tensioners.....ouch.
Last edited by Skinthespin; 08-17-2018 at 04:44 PM.
#60
I have found a way to check the timing belt and make sure it does not have engine destroying slack.
Could some of you also verify.
The timing chain is visible by removing the oil filler cap. I was able to push up against it to see if there was any deflection. (btw, also a place to lube the chain should you be starting it after a month of storage and the chain was bone dry)
I was most impressed to find that the chain had oil on it despite not being run for a week and really thin oil viscosity. Which typically runs down to the pan as fast as it can.
Could some of you also verify.
The timing chain is visible by removing the oil filler cap. I was able to push up against it to see if there was any deflection. (btw, also a place to lube the chain should you be starting it after a month of storage and the chain was bone dry)
I was most impressed to find that the chain had oil on it despite not being run for a week and really thin oil viscosity. Which typically runs down to the pan as fast as it can.