New Battery
#21
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,014
Received 1,410 Likes
on
876 Posts
Hey . . . don't sweat it too hard. Purpose in doing that write-up, based on many years of experience by many, was to de-mystify and, most importantly . . . produce a systematic process of identifying which succession of fuses to pull. With the write-up and wiring diagram specific for your MY, even the 60min "sleep time" sees the fault isolation, if not the fix, emerge quickly. Please let us know your results.
Best wishes,
Ken
Best wishes,
Ken
#22
Thanks so much. From reading that I understand quiescent drain is normal at rest drain. I knew of it (clock etc.)but had no idea there was a 60min shut down period . First thing I have to do is read/study until I understand the electrical section on my car in the JTIS as suggested and come back to these tests.. Anyway my standing voltage was 12.3 last night and 11.9 12hrs later so I'm pretty sure I'm dealing with more than at rest drain. I have over 14v charging when started then settles to around 13v after running a bit so if I start it every 12hrs I'm good until I figure this out.. I'm guessing this happened when I started it with the old battery with standing 12.1v that dropped to 9 volts with the cranking load. I'm surprised the control module works on 9v.
They work rather intermittently below about 11V so 9V can be a nightmare.
Alternator sounds to be working
#23
Thanks Jag..and Cat. That 12.3v was because the new battery went dead with the new standing load on it and wasn't charged all the way.. After driving 20mi it was 12.6 at shut down then settled at 12.5 in 5min or so.. I've been keeping tabs on this slow drain and I lost about 1/10th a volt every 4 hrs. yesterday and went from 12.5v to 12.3v in 8hrs and last night.
__________________________________________________ __________
I had no problems with the battery change. Everything works..radio,window settings, idle.. the car runs great.. I didn't have any standing load on the old battery. The car somehow came up with it . I've done a bit of reading on this and found there are a few battery drain problems that even the dealers couldn't find so some just kept their cars on trickle chargers. I'm still bugging you all that maybe someone had the same problem and found an answer..All that said I think the problem my have been caused before the battery change when the volts dropped to 9v during cranking... Thanks everyone here
__________________________________________________ __________
I had no problems with the battery change. Everything works..radio,window settings, idle.. the car runs great.. I didn't have any standing load on the old battery. The car somehow came up with it . I've done a bit of reading on this and found there are a few battery drain problems that even the dealers couldn't find so some just kept their cars on trickle chargers. I'm still bugging you all that maybe someone had the same problem and found an answer..All that said I think the problem my have been caused before the battery change when the volts dropped to 9v during cranking... Thanks everyone here
Last edited by ZenFly; 04-22-2017 at 07:38 AM.
#24
Hi,
The problem with the battery is that the charging system was designed for lead antimony type, they needed a lower charging rate. The new maintenance free batteries which are the only type that is available now require a higher charging rate.
The majority of the S types do not produce this voltage so the battery does not get fully charged and the PATS system (car alarm) slowly discharges the battery. This why a battery tender is a good idea.
The problem with the battery is that the charging system was designed for lead antimony type, they needed a lower charging rate. The new maintenance free batteries which are the only type that is available now require a higher charging rate.
The majority of the S types do not produce this voltage so the battery does not get fully charged and the PATS system (car alarm) slowly discharges the battery. This why a battery tender is a good idea.
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (04-23-2017)
#25
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,014
Received 1,410 Likes
on
876 Posts
. . . and, in line with Jaguar's permissible 30mA after 60 minutes, most fault-free S-Types (and XK and XJ contemparies) tested, actually revealed QCDs of low teens . . . ie <15mA. A few measured lower still . . . <10mA.
At that rate and with new, externally fully charged battery (say 12.9V), it takes about 8 weeks of unattended "sleep" to reach "low 12s" (say <12.3V) when "false faults" will have emerged. That said, use of a smart charger (battery tender) to maintain at least 12.6V, not only solves that problem . . . experience shows it enhances maximum battery life by maintaining battery voltage at optimum fully charged condition.
Cheers,
Ken
At that rate and with new, externally fully charged battery (say 12.9V), it takes about 8 weeks of unattended "sleep" to reach "low 12s" (say <12.3V) when "false faults" will have emerged. That said, use of a smart charger (battery tender) to maintain at least 12.6V, not only solves that problem . . . experience shows it enhances maximum battery life by maintaining battery voltage at optimum fully charged condition.
Cheers,
Ken
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (04-23-2017)
#26
Thanks both of you above for that info.. I live in a condo and there are no outlets in the parking lot so a trickle charger is out of the question for me.. The Battery that was in before was a regular Interstate that I had no such problem with for almost two years since I bought the car and did not need a charger .It was replaced with a Walmart Maxx that Walmart insured me was the correct battery. Was that Interstate a special battery? It never gave any trouble until it dropped to 9v during cranking load and the lights and beeping began.
Last edited by ZenFly; 04-22-2017 at 08:38 PM.
#27
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/s...-s-type-64372/
FWIW, I have fitted small 1.5W panels available from Northern Tool/Harbor Freight for less than $10 (on sale) to the 05 and the 95 X300. Both feeding separate VDC 12V On-Board conditioners, which saved me from fitting regulators.
http://www.batteryminders.com/12v-onboard-desulfator
Last edited by aholbro1; 04-22-2017 at 09:08 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (04-23-2017)
#28
Not so fast, there, Kimosabe! While you needn't go to the extreme as I did for my daughter's car, you can follow Gus' excellent lead linked in post #7 here:
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/s...-s-type-64372/
FWIW, I have fitted small 1.5W panels available from Northern Tool/Harbor Freight for less than $10 (on sale) to the 05 and the 95 X300. Both feeding separate VDC 12V On-Board conditioners, which saved me from fitting regulators.
BatteryMINDer® Model OBD-12: 12V On-Board Desulfator
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/s...-s-type-64372/
FWIW, I have fitted small 1.5W panels available from Northern Tool/Harbor Freight for less than $10 (on sale) to the 05 and the 95 X300. Both feeding separate VDC 12V On-Board conditioners, which saved me from fitting regulators.
BatteryMINDer® Model OBD-12: 12V On-Board Desulfator
#29
How long have you had the new battery? Most new batteries aren't sold fully charged, strange as that may seem.
Then consider what is your typical drive routine? If mostly short trips, headlights on, defrost on, heater fan on high, seat heaters in 'rump roast' mode, etc., your battery may not be getting much of a charge, if anything. And if the new battery wasn't fully charged (I'd be VERY surprised if it was), that would aggravate the condition.
I vaguely remember reading a car needs at least 20 minutes of running to replenish the energy expended to start the engine. Any less than that, plus the addition of high electrical demands, puts your battery behind the curve. FWIW, I live 35 minutes from work and so far my battery is doing just fine.
#30
Interesting discussion.
How long have you had the new battery? Most new batteries aren't sold fully charged, strange as that may seem.
Then consider what is your typical drive routine? If mostly short trips, headlights on, defrost on, heater fan on high, seat heaters in 'rump roast' mode, etc., your battery may not be getting much of a charge, if anything. And if the new battery wasn't fully charged (I'd be VERY surprised if it was), that would aggravate the condition.
I vaguely remember reading a car needs at least 20 minutes of running to replenish the energy expended to start the engine. Any less than that, plus the addition of high electrical demands, puts your battery behind the curve. FWIW, I live 35 minutes from work and so far my battery is doing just fine.
How long have you had the new battery? Most new batteries aren't sold fully charged, strange as that may seem.
Then consider what is your typical drive routine? If mostly short trips, headlights on, defrost on, heater fan on high, seat heaters in 'rump roast' mode, etc., your battery may not be getting much of a charge, if anything. And if the new battery wasn't fully charged (I'd be VERY surprised if it was), that would aggravate the condition.
I vaguely remember reading a car needs at least 20 minutes of running to replenish the energy expended to start the engine. Any less than that, plus the addition of high electrical demands, puts your battery behind the curve. FWIW, I live 35 minutes from work and so far my battery is doing just fine.
Last edited by ZenFly; 04-23-2017 at 04:47 AM.
#31
Actually it is a design feature of the car that it initially changes at 14 v then after a specific time it goes down to 13 volts. It is not dependent on how much the battery is charged.
The maintenance free (lead-calcium) batteries need to be permanently charged at 14 volts. This means that your battery is not being completely recharged.
When fully charged it will have a minimum of 12.6 volts after 3 minutes with all the lights turned on after being charged for 20 hours.
So depending on what is turned on your car when you drive you probably only have 80% charge in the battery.
I put my battery on a tender once a month to ensure that I do not have this program of false codes occurring.
The maintenance free (lead-calcium) batteries need to be permanently charged at 14 volts. This means that your battery is not being completely recharged.
When fully charged it will have a minimum of 12.6 volts after 3 minutes with all the lights turned on after being charged for 20 hours.
So depending on what is turned on your car when you drive you probably only have 80% charge in the battery.
I put my battery on a tender once a month to ensure that I do not have this program of false codes occurring.
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (04-23-2017)
#32
Actually it is a design feature of the car that it initially changes at 14 v then after a specific time it goes down to 13 volts. It is not dependent on how much the battery is charged.
The maintenance free (lead-calcium) batteries need to be permanently charged at 14 volts. This means that your battery is not being completely recharged.
When fully charged it will have a minimum of 12.6 volts after 3 minutes with all the lights turned on after being charged for 20 hours.
So depending on what is turned on your car when you drive you probably only have 80% charge in the battery.
I put my battery on a tender once a month to ensure that I do not have this program of false codes occurring.
The maintenance free (lead-calcium) batteries need to be permanently charged at 14 volts. This means that your battery is not being completely recharged.
When fully charged it will have a minimum of 12.6 volts after 3 minutes with all the lights turned on after being charged for 20 hours.
So depending on what is turned on your car when you drive you probably only have 80% charge in the battery.
I put my battery on a tender once a month to ensure that I do not have this program of false codes occurring.
#33
Have you confirmed an actual parasitic drain? In other words, after the 60 minute wait, you've still got X amount of current when it should be only a tiny value.
Or is your assumption of a parasitic drain based solely on the voltage reading? The bulk of the problem could be as simple as the new battery being defective and not holding a charge. Rare, but not impossible.
I only ask because the problem has started (or become prevalent) with the battery replacement.
Some cheap troubleshooting ideas:
1) Swap in a known-good (and fully charged) battery from another vehicle.
2) Keep the existing suspect battery installed and disconnect it at night. Measure the voltage when first disconnected and then again in the morning. If the voltage still drops excessively while disconnected, you know the battery is bad.
3) A little more involved, but appealing to my inner geek: Fully charge and then disconnect the battery. Rig up a test load of a normal sleep mode drain. Was it 15mA or something like that? An 800 ohm resistor should give you approximately 15mA at a nominal 12 volts. Take before and after voltage readings to see if your new battery can handle a normal overnight drain.
Or is your assumption of a parasitic drain based solely on the voltage reading? The bulk of the problem could be as simple as the new battery being defective and not holding a charge. Rare, but not impossible.
I only ask because the problem has started (or become prevalent) with the battery replacement.
Some cheap troubleshooting ideas:
1) Swap in a known-good (and fully charged) battery from another vehicle.
2) Keep the existing suspect battery installed and disconnect it at night. Measure the voltage when first disconnected and then again in the morning. If the voltage still drops excessively while disconnected, you know the battery is bad.
3) A little more involved, but appealing to my inner geek: Fully charge and then disconnect the battery. Rig up a test load of a normal sleep mode drain. Was it 15mA or something like that? An 800 ohm resistor should give you approximately 15mA at a nominal 12 volts. Take before and after voltage readings to see if your new battery can handle a normal overnight drain.
The following users liked this post:
ZenFly (04-24-2017)
#34
There are hundreds if not thousands of posts on many forums about this same problem that turned out to be ignition switch, wiper motor , radio , defrost and on and on.. I have to do a real parasitic drain test pulling fuses one at a time but before I do that I want to get it on a real charger that shouldn't take very long when it's already well over 12v. The fact it only drains to 12v overnight and that I use it every day is a plus but I know I can't let it stand 3-4 days.
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ ____________________________
I went to find the JTIS CD I bought 1.5yrs ago then dah! I remembered it didn't work on my Mac and the old laptop we have didn't have the right bits or something.. I googled for a download but they were all dead ends. Once I find the culprit I may very well need a wiring diagram.. any ideas?
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ ____________________________
I went to find the JTIS CD I bought 1.5yrs ago then dah! I remembered it didn't work on my Mac and the old laptop we have didn't have the right bits or something.. I googled for a download but they were all dead ends. Once I find the culprit I may very well need a wiring diagram.. any ideas?
Last edited by ZenFly; 04-23-2017 at 07:58 AM.
#35
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,014
Received 1,410 Likes
on
876 Posts
The case for a new battery failing is perhaps, not as common, but well known examples are here also.
Cheers and best wishes.,
Ken
Last edited by cat_as_trophy; 04-23-2017 at 07:44 AM.
#36
JTIS is a free download in the stickies. I wasn't suggesting the solar charger to cover the problem, per se, only to insure your battery remains fully charged if you do short trips and such. Plus, these cars love a toke on "the juice" if, as you remark above, they sit for three or four days. Granted, they should still function, even after several weeks of standing alone, yet they still love a toke on the juice!
In the case where I fitted the 5W VDC, that was to combat VERY short, night time trips, and lots of them, with never any sustained running. She was on-campus and walked everywhere during the day, but didn't feel safe doing so after dark, so almost ALL driving was the distance of a 10 min walk. However, FWIW, here a number of years down the road, the VDC did cover for an intermittent parasitic drain. Car always started and performed fine, sitting two weeks unmolested and all. However, I parked it inside the shop where the sun couldn't get to it and it was dead in a week! Turned out to be the MFS flashing the headlights and turning other lights on for various durations at all hours. Follow Cat's guide and you'll ferret it out.
In the case where I fitted the 5W VDC, that was to combat VERY short, night time trips, and lots of them, with never any sustained running. She was on-campus and walked everywhere during the day, but didn't feel safe doing so after dark, so almost ALL driving was the distance of a 10 min walk. However, FWIW, here a number of years down the road, the VDC did cover for an intermittent parasitic drain. Car always started and performed fine, sitting two weeks unmolested and all. However, I parked it inside the shop where the sun couldn't get to it and it was dead in a week! Turned out to be the MFS flashing the headlights and turning other lights on for various durations at all hours. Follow Cat's guide and you'll ferret it out.
#37
There are hundreds if not thousands of posts on many forums about this same problem that turned out to be ignition switch, wiper motor , radio , defrost and on and on.. I have to do a real parasitic drain test pulling fuses one at a time but before I do that I want to get it on a real charger that shouldn't take very long when it's already well over 12v. The fact it only drains to 12v overnight and that I use it every day is a plus but I know I can't let it stand 3-4 days.
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ ____________________________
I went to find the JTIS CD I bought 1.5yrs ago then dah! I remembered it didn't work on my Mac and the old laptop we have didn't have the right bits or something.. I googled for a download but they were all dead ends. Once I find the culprit I may very well need a wiring diagram.. any ideas?
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ ____________________________
I went to find the JTIS CD I bought 1.5yrs ago then dah! I remembered it didn't work on my Mac and the old laptop we have didn't have the right bits or something.. I googled for a download but they were all dead ends. Once I find the culprit I may very well need a wiring diagram.. any ideas?
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (04-23-2017)
#38
go to JagRepair.com - Jaguar Repair Information Resource. you can download the workshop manual as pdf and all of the wiring diagrams as well.
http://jagrepair.com/images/AutoRepa...cal-2006on.pdf
#39
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: Pawleys Island, SC USA (formerly from Tabernacle, NJ USA)
Posts: 3,018
Received 182 Likes
on
158 Posts
Battery Tender Solar Charger for untethered battery charging
Not so fast, there, Kimosabe! While you needn't go to the extreme as I did for my daughter's car, you can follow Gus' excellent lead linked in post #7 here:
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/s...-s-type-64372/
FWIW, I have fitted small 1.5W panels available from Northern Tool/Harbor Freight for less than $10 (on sale) to the 05 and the 95 X300. Both feeding separate VDC 12V On-Board conditioners, which saved me from fitting regulators.
BatteryMINDer® Model OBD-12: 12V On-Board Desulfator
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/s...-s-type-64372/
FWIW, I have fitted small 1.5W panels available from Northern Tool/Harbor Freight for less than $10 (on sale) to the 05 and the 95 X300. Both feeding separate VDC 12V On-Board conditioners, which saved me from fitting regulators.
BatteryMINDer® Model OBD-12: 12V On-Board Desulfator
5-Watt Solar Tender Charger #021-1163
NOTE: it should be noted that Deltran, the company that makes Battery Tender, will only ship this product to addresses within the United States. I realized that as I was purchasing one of these solar chargers today for myself.
Last edited by Jumpin' Jag Flash; 04-23-2017 at 01:05 PM.
The following users liked this post:
cat_as_trophy (04-24-2017)
#40
Here is Battery Tender's 5W solar charger/maintainer with built-in controller to prevent overcharging; $80 and a 5 yr warranty. Seems perfect for cars that don't have access to an electrical connection for a standard charger. Looks like a modern commercial version of what both you and Gus designed years ago, no?
5-Watt Solar Tender Charger #021-1163
NOTE: it should be noted that Deltran, the company that makes Battery Tender, will only ship this product to addresses within the United States. I realized that as I was purchasing one of these solar chargers today for myself.
5-Watt Solar Tender Charger #021-1163
NOTE: it should be noted that Deltran, the company that makes Battery Tender, will only ship this product to addresses within the United States. I realized that as I was purchasing one of these solar chargers today for myself.
The following 2 users liked this post by ZenFly:
cat_as_trophy (04-24-2017),
Jumpin' Jag Flash (04-23-2017)