What spark plugs?
#1
#2
#3
I looked at plugs online and found they ranged in price from a couple bucks to over $20 each! I shoulda stuck with my diesels! Most of them were in the $5-$8 range. Do I really need a platinum plug with 4 electrodes? Or will a factory (OEM replacement) plug do the trick? Is there a noticeable advantage to the "super plugs"? Spending over $150 on spark plugs boggles my mind!
#4
The following are merely my opinions, based on certain amount of personal experience. I'm sure someone with more knowledge will chime in if I'm leading you astray.
1) Champion spark plugs:
I'm 100% with you on the Champion hate. In a long and varied mechanical career (primarily on motorcycles), the ONLY brand of plugs I've had a problem with were Champions.
2) "Super" plugs:
I think a lot of this falls into the "snake oil" category, or at the very least the "these cost more, so they gotta be better ... right?" mindset.
Certainly spark plug technology has come a long way over the years, but you can buy a nice set of Bosch, NGK (or whatever brand!) multiple electrode plugs at your local auto parts store (or Wal-Mart!) for a very reasonable price.
While a $20 spark plug might test superior in some respect on sophisticated test apparatus, I seriously doubt there would be any noticeable difference in performance or longevity in a real-life situation.
These certainly aren't Formula 1 engines we're dealing with!
Again, strictly my not-so-humble opinion. Yours may vary.
Good luck,
Retro
1) Champion spark plugs:
I'm 100% with you on the Champion hate. In a long and varied mechanical career (primarily on motorcycles), the ONLY brand of plugs I've had a problem with were Champions.
2) "Super" plugs:
I think a lot of this falls into the "snake oil" category, or at the very least the "these cost more, so they gotta be better ... right?" mindset.
Certainly spark plug technology has come a long way over the years, but you can buy a nice set of Bosch, NGK (or whatever brand!) multiple electrode plugs at your local auto parts store (or Wal-Mart!) for a very reasonable price.
While a $20 spark plug might test superior in some respect on sophisticated test apparatus, I seriously doubt there would be any noticeable difference in performance or longevity in a real-life situation.
These certainly aren't Formula 1 engines we're dealing with!
Again, strictly my not-so-humble opinion. Yours may vary.
Good luck,
Retro
#5
The following are merely my opinions, based on certain amount of personal experience. I'm sure someone with more knowledge will chime in if I'm leading you astray.
1) Champion spark plugs:
I'm 100% with you on the Champion hate. In a long and varied mechanical career (primarily on motorcycles), the ONLY brand of plugs I've had a problem with were Champions.
2) "Super" plugs:
I think a lot of this falls into the "snake oil" category, or at the very least the "these cost more, so they gotta be better ... right?" mindset.
Certainly spark plug technology has come a long way over the years, but you can buy a nice set of Bosch, NGK (or whatever brand!) multiple electrode plugs at your local auto parts store (or Wal-Mart!) for a very reasonable price.
While a $20 spark plug might test superior in some respect on sophisticated test apparatus, I seriously doubt there would be any noticeable difference in performance or longevity in a real-life situation.
These certainly aren't Formula 1 engines we're dealing with!
Again, strictly my not-so-humble opinion. Yours may vary.
Good luck,
Retro
1) Champion spark plugs:
I'm 100% with you on the Champion hate. In a long and varied mechanical career (primarily on motorcycles), the ONLY brand of plugs I've had a problem with were Champions.
2) "Super" plugs:
I think a lot of this falls into the "snake oil" category, or at the very least the "these cost more, so they gotta be better ... right?" mindset.
Certainly spark plug technology has come a long way over the years, but you can buy a nice set of Bosch, NGK (or whatever brand!) multiple electrode plugs at your local auto parts store (or Wal-Mart!) for a very reasonable price.
While a $20 spark plug might test superior in some respect on sophisticated test apparatus, I seriously doubt there would be any noticeable difference in performance or longevity in a real-life situation.
These certainly aren't Formula 1 engines we're dealing with!
Again, strictly my not-so-humble opinion. Yours may vary.
Good luck,
Retro
#7
Trending Topics
#8
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,255 Likes
on
1,840 Posts
2) "Super" plugs:
I think a lot of this falls into the "snake oil" category, or at the very least the "these cost more, so they gotta be better ... right?" mindset.
Certainly spark plug technology has come a long way over the years, but you can buy a nice set of Bosch, NGK (or whatever brand!) multiple electrode plugs at your local auto parts store (or Wal-Mart!) for a very reasonable price.
While a $20 spark plug might test superior in some respect on sophisticated test apparatus, I seriously doubt there would be any noticeable difference in performance or longevity in a real-life situation.
These certainly aren't Formula 1 engines we're dealing with!
I think a lot of this falls into the "snake oil" category, or at the very least the "these cost more, so they gotta be better ... right?" mindset.
Certainly spark plug technology has come a long way over the years, but you can buy a nice set of Bosch, NGK (or whatever brand!) multiple electrode plugs at your local auto parts store (or Wal-Mart!) for a very reasonable price.
While a $20 spark plug might test superior in some respect on sophisticated test apparatus, I seriously doubt there would be any noticeable difference in performance or longevity in a real-life situation.
These certainly aren't Formula 1 engines we're dealing with!
Your opinions are well founded on the 'super' plugs regarding performance. Assuming that the correct heat range and length of plug has been chosen (ie the electrodes are projecting into the combustion chamber as designed) no plug will give better or worse performance than another. Basically, a spark is a spark.
Where the super-zoomy ultra platinum/iridium/unobtanium expensive types have a clear advantage and why they're used by the OEMs on newer cars is simply for durability. It's not rare for these plugs to last 100,000 miles/160,000kms. This longevity is required for pollution certification.
Whether it's worthwhile putting them in an older car from a cost point of view, I don't know.
#9
I have to agree with pretty much all that has gone before me here. Let's face it, we are now talking in general about cars that are heading for 20 years old, with 50 year old engine designs.
So is your unobtanium plug going to help make things better, I doubt it.
Modern engines are different, with different alloys used, different thermal characteristics, higher rev ranges, lower emissions quotas, the list goes on.
Call me cynical, or just approaching grumpy old git status (whatever you want), but I am of the opinion that OEM status, by a third party manufacturer is today achieved from a purely economics basis.
Spec sheet given to plug manufacturers A, B, C, all make plugs that agree with the specs, but C gives the best deal to the car manufacturer.
C, becomes new OEM supplier.
Does any of that help my out of date, out of production XJ40, no! so I will use whatever is the best price and meets the recommended specs for my car.
I really don't need a plug that is guaranteed not to misfire at 20,000rpm and will last up to 100,000 miles, my 20 year old car will never aspire to either.
And can you imagine the response, if in 20 years time I post up into this thread, saying that I am now due to change my plugs for the first time in a generation.
So to Muleears, your money, your choice, I have had Champions, and NGK and a mixture of the two, never had any problems. Now plug leads, ah, that is another chapter, (you can have the best plugs, the best coil, the best dizzy cap, but if the spaghetti can't deliver then you have negated everything).
But even here, a non leaking simple cheap lead, is always going to be better than a broken down expensive jobbie.
Let us know, what you decide to do. As you can see, your simple question, gets the juices flowing. LOL
So is your unobtanium plug going to help make things better, I doubt it.
Modern engines are different, with different alloys used, different thermal characteristics, higher rev ranges, lower emissions quotas, the list goes on.
Call me cynical, or just approaching grumpy old git status (whatever you want), but I am of the opinion that OEM status, by a third party manufacturer is today achieved from a purely economics basis.
Spec sheet given to plug manufacturers A, B, C, all make plugs that agree with the specs, but C gives the best deal to the car manufacturer.
C, becomes new OEM supplier.
Does any of that help my out of date, out of production XJ40, no! so I will use whatever is the best price and meets the recommended specs for my car.
I really don't need a plug that is guaranteed not to misfire at 20,000rpm and will last up to 100,000 miles, my 20 year old car will never aspire to either.
And can you imagine the response, if in 20 years time I post up into this thread, saying that I am now due to change my plugs for the first time in a generation.
So to Muleears, your money, your choice, I have had Champions, and NGK and a mixture of the two, never had any problems. Now plug leads, ah, that is another chapter, (you can have the best plugs, the best coil, the best dizzy cap, but if the spaghetti can't deliver then you have negated everything).
But even here, a non leaking simple cheap lead, is always going to be better than a broken down expensive jobbie.
Let us know, what you decide to do. As you can see, your simple question, gets the juices flowing. LOL
#10
#11
I was wondering if anyone has tried the Bosch Platinum +4 plugs I got a set of them today for my 98 XJ8 L 4.0. A friend swears by them this is the first time I will be using them.
I agree with Champions being horrible, they are the worse plug I ever used never had any luck with them.
John
J.A.N.E Member
I agree with Champions being horrible, they are the worse plug I ever used never had any luck with them.
John
J.A.N.E Member
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
FS[MidAtlantic]: 1997 XJ6 VDP $3,900 - Very RARE Anthracite on Warm Charcoal
42Ajd
PRIVATE For Sale / Trade or Buy Classifieds
0
09-26-2015 07:04 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)