I was told by a Jag repair shop to buy a Robbins 2422R top like this: ROBBINS-2422R - Jaguar 1989-95 XJS, XJR Convertible Top, Fits to Factory Glass Window which is $663.00
or EZ ON such as the one sold here: https://www.topsonline.com/model/Con...aguar_XJS.html - $ 555.00

But I also found these, about the same price: Jaguar XJS All Convertible Tops & Power Window Parts - Hydro-E-Lectric $ 503.00 from Hydro-E-Lectric
and: https://www.autotopsdirect.com/1989-...08-xjs-001.htm $528.00 from AutoTopsDirect.com
and: https://www.convertibletopguys.com/c...-XJS-Cabriolet $489.95 from convertibletopguys.com
and: https://www.ebay.com/itm/JAGUAR-XJS-...8AAMXQVT9TCoHJ from Auto Seats and Tops on ebay $ 595.00 (includes headliner)

All are in the original Sonnenland classic (original?) canvas fabric, mine is black, also in Tan, Blue, and Brown, plus cables and rear window gaskets.

Does anyone have experience with a cheaper brand like some of these?
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Jaguar-XJS-...MAAOSw2XFUbSLm Diamond Mall, AKA D.D Auto Accessories on ebay, $389.00
or: https://www.germanautotops.com/jagua...existing-glass, $395.00 from GermanAutoTops.com
More importantly, is there enough of a difference in quality, design, materials, to justify spending more for longevity, ease of installation, etc.

Also, has anybody ever bought the mat or any mat pieces (fabric or foam) from these guys or anywhere else? Raw Materials for Auto Trimming from World Upholstery & Trim
Any recommendations or comments will be appreciated!