Buying an XK with a replacement motor good or bad?
#21
From what I've read, there have been 3-5 (not sure the number) attempts to redesign the water pump and I believe the last iteration is a fix. Others will have to provide part numbers.
There are a few solutions for the lack of gauges, none of which are optimal but all are workable. I would drive it as Shemp and Ranchero suggested. They do (replacement engines) often feel a little off and you should drive another 5.0 to compare.
The following users liked this post:
Matt Harrell (09-07-2017)
#22
The following users liked this post:
Matt Harrell (09-07-2017)
#24
The following users liked this post:
Matt Harrell (09-07-2017)
#28
If you have an Android phone you can buy an OBD reader and a the Torque app for less then $30. Then you will get temperature, voltage and many other readings that you can select to put on the phone. Finally you can buy a magnetized clamp that will fit into the CD slot for less then $15 on either Ebay or Amazon where you will find the OBD reader as well as the Torque app. As a bonus then you can use Wayze or Google maps on a regular basis and not worry about updating the DVD GPS.
Also I think driving both the engine swapped vehicle and another unswapped vehicle is a great idea. By the way, you may want the selected car subjected to a pre-purchase inspection for both mechanics and body damage. Total cost for both should be less than $500-600.
Also I think driving both the engine swapped vehicle and another unswapped vehicle is a great idea. By the way, you may want the selected car subjected to a pre-purchase inspection for both mechanics and body damage. Total cost for both should be less than $500-600.
#29
If you have an Android phone you can buy an OBD reader and a the Torque app for less then $30. Then you will get temperature, voltage and many other readings that you can select to put on the phone. Finally you can buy a magnetized clamp that will fit into the CD slot for less then $15 on either Ebay or Amazon where you will find the OBD reader as well as the Torque app. As a bonus then you can use Wayze or Google maps on a regular basis and not worry about updating the DVD GPS.
1. The OBD/Bluetooth interface is always on and drawing power when it it plugged in. Even with the car shut off it draws power.
2. If I want to monitor the engine temperature I have to remember to start the app on my phone and connect to the OBD reader whenever I get in the car.
3. I use Google maps for navigation on my phone. If engine temperature is being displayed, I can't see the map.
4. When connected to the Bluetooth OBD reader it cannot connect to the car's Bluetooth hands free phone system.
For those reasons I opted for a dedicated temperature display that turns itself off when the car is off.
#30
2. If I want to monitor the engine temperature I have to remember to start the app on my phone and connect to the OBD reader whenever I get in the car.
3. I use Google maps for navigation on my phone. If engine temperature is being displayed, I can't see the map.
4. When connected to the Bluetooth OBD reader it cannot connect to the car's Bluetooth hands free phone system.
For those reasons I opted for a dedicated temperature display that turns itself off when the car is off.
The following users liked this post:
ralphwg (09-09-2017)
#31
The OBD socket on my 07 XKR still supplies power after the car has shutdown. I have just leant in through the open window and plugged my wifi ELM327 box in to the socket and was greeted with a red flashing led and that is on a car that hasn't been touched for 2 hours.
#32
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: Naperville, Illinois USA
Posts: 4,571
Received 1,894 Likes
on
1,285 Posts
There are units, including the wifi unit I have, that shuts itself off a short time after the ignition is turned off. Just read the features of the unit before purchasing.
#33
I am sure the X50 is not for everyone. It works for me and addresses my concerns.
I do have wireless ELM327 interfaces in my other cars for reading or clearing any codes that my pop up. The other cars all have OEM temperature gauges though.
Last edited by davchr; 09-08-2017 at 10:02 AM.
#34
The following users liked this post:
Matt Harrell (09-08-2017)
#35
#36
#37
A new engine only, and while being installed by a dealership may be an advantage over a Non Jag shop (perhaps), it's still a far cry from a factory install. I've swapped enough engines in my time to recognize there is a difference. Back to Ranchero and Shemp's advice. Drive it side by side with a non lemon car if you can. There's a reason it's going for $21k
The following users liked this post:
Queen and Country (09-09-2017)
#38
Yes. Brand new OEM replacement engine from Jaguar. The dealer replaced the engine and the owner then put on another 12k miles before trading it in at a different dealer.
There was nothing about the motor being replaced on carfax, I figured it out after talking to two different Jag dealers and they both confirmed the engine swap.
Apparently not everything gets on the car fax report.
There was nothing about the motor being replaced on carfax, I figured it out after talking to two different Jag dealers and they both confirmed the engine swap.
Apparently not everything gets on the car fax report.