Hi guys,
Is there a consensus for the best synthetic motor oil. I checked YouTube and there is no definitive answer on which of the many brand names are superior or best. You guys are very knowledgeable , so I thought I'd post my question here to see what you have to say about the best engine oil.
Thank you
Is there a consensus for the best synthetic motor oil. I checked YouTube and there is no definitive answer on which of the many brand names are superior or best. You guys are very knowledgeable , so I thought I'd post my question here to see what you have to say about the best engine oil.
Thank you
Veteran Member
plums
Veteran Member
close
- Join DateFeb 2011
- Locationon-the-edge
- Posts:9,733
-
Likes:1,037
-
Liked:2,201 Times in 1,633 Posts
Best is probably a really bad word to include in an oil thread.
Highly recommended, popular, well regarded might be better terms.
As for best ... under what criteria?
Highly recommended, popular, well regarded might be better terms.
As for best ... under what criteria?
Quote:
Highly recommended, popular, well regarded might be better terms.
As for best ... under what criteria?
Withstanding high heat / temperatures, cold startup and viscosity breakdown.Originally Posted by plums
Best is probably a really bad word to include in an oil thread.Highly recommended, popular, well regarded might be better terms.
As for best ... under what criteria?
Also, bring a true synthetic instead of dino oil mix formulation.
Thanks
Veteran Member
plums
Veteran Member
close
- Join DateFeb 2011
- Locationon-the-edge
- Posts:9,733
-
Likes:1,037
-
Liked:2,201 Times in 1,633 Posts
In that case, you may like Castrol 0W40 European which has "Made in Belgium"
on the back label.
You should consider HTHS as that number is very much related to bearing
and cylinder bore wear. You want 3.5 or greater. The above oil meets
ACEA A3/B4 which means it has HTHS >= 3.5 amongst other characteristics.
All ACEA A3/B4 must "remain in grade" over the oil change interval.
on the back label.
You should consider HTHS as that number is very much related to bearing
and cylinder bore wear. You want 3.5 or greater. The above oil meets
ACEA A3/B4 which means it has HTHS >= 3.5 amongst other characteristics.
All ACEA A3/B4 must "remain in grade" over the oil change interval.
Quote:
on the back label.
You should consider HTHS as that number is very much related to bearing
and cylinder bore wear. You want 3.5 or greater. The above oil meets
ACEA A3/B4 which means it has HTHS >= 3.5 amongst other characteristics.
All ACEA A3/B4 must "remain in grade" over the oil change interval.
Originally Posted by plums
In that case, you may like Castrol 0W40 European which has "Made in Belgium"on the back label.
You should consider HTHS as that number is very much related to bearing
and cylinder bore wear. You want 3.5 or greater. The above oil meets
ACEA A3/B4 which means it has HTHS >= 3.5 amongst other characteristics.
All ACEA A3/B4 must "remain in grade" over the oil change interval.
Regarding the Castrol 0W40 European, I don't think it's available here in the states. Yes ... No ?
Veteran Member
plums
Veteran Member
close
- Join DateFeb 2011
- Locationon-the-edge
- Posts:9,733
-
Likes:1,037
-
Liked:2,201 Times in 1,633 Posts
It's available.
Try Walmart.
Try Walmart.
Veteran Member
Mulmur
Veteran Member
close
- Join DateMay 2014
- LocationMulmur, Ontario, Canada
- Posts:1,420
-
Likes:377
-
Liked:265 Times in 211 Posts
The Castrol that Jaguar recommends (I think its called Professional or European) is from pure synthetic stock or so I'm told.. Its my understanding that Amsoil is as well.
There are some oil threads on this forum that got into this topic and other brands were mentioned.
If you open the discussion to oil weight you should have a never ending supply of information and opinions to read.
Lawrence
There are some oil threads on this forum that got into this topic and other brands were mentioned.
If you open the discussion to oil weight you should have a never ending supply of information and opinions to read.
Lawrence
Unhingd
Veteran Member
close
- Join DateDec 2014
- LocationMaryland, US
- Posts:16,948
-
Likes:1,306
-
Liked:4,727 Times in 3,407 Posts
There is really no need to look any farther than the Castrol Edge Professional that is recommended by Jag.
Veteran Member
Quote:
+1Originally Posted by Unhingd
There is really no need to look any farther than the Castrol Edge Professional that is recommended by Jag.
Especially when Jag can deny a motor claim if "wrong" oil is found in a failed engine. I was warned by service dept.
Mikey

close
- Join DateOct 2009
- LocationPerth Ontario Canada
- Posts:11,057
-
Likes:503
-
Liked:2,271 Times in 1,847 Posts
Quote:
Is there a consensus for the best synthetic motor oil.
No.Originally Posted by Ubad2
Hi guys,Is there a consensus for the best synthetic motor oil.
Just like asking 'what's the best beer' there is no consensus. Some people will fight to the death arguing their opinion no matter how wrong they might be.
Use the oil specified by Jag and/or required by your warranty. Abandon any thinking that there might be something better than will make more than half a gnat's f*rt improvement.
Veteran Member
Hey Mikey, Just remembering the good ol' days when you used to engage in said debates. I think it was Jagular that finally pushed you over the edge. I could just hear the frustration as I read your responses.
Mikey

close
- Join DateOct 2009
- LocationPerth Ontario Canada
- Posts:11,057
-
Likes:503
-
Liked:2,271 Times in 1,847 Posts
I'd forgotten about him. Guess he's gone? 




