alternator overcharging
#1
alternator overcharging
my battery couldn't start my cat the other day so i got a new battery and bingo i got it back on the road. So i went to my auto electrician who put an analog multimeter on the new battery whiles the the cat was still running and the gauge moved to the RED which he explains means that my alternator is overcharging the battery.
now he tells me i need a new alternator, else my new battery too will be gone in a few weeks time. This is my third battery in 1yr
is this very common on your cars?what can i do to this overcharging alternator apart from replacing it?
now he tells me i need a new alternator, else my new battery too will be gone in a few weeks time. This is my third battery in 1yr
is this very common on your cars?what can i do to this overcharging alternator apart from replacing it?
#3
ok so it turned out that the alternator has no problem at all rather the cells in my battery were weak due to drying out of the acid. In fact a series of test were done to confirm this and this include removing the negative terminal from the battery whiles the engine is still running and placing it back on. If there are not sparks whiles u palce the terminal on then the alternator is fine. Am sure this is a primitive way of checking but it really helps if u don't have all those digital stuff> Currently i have a new battery on and all seem to be going very well with no battery light on the dash.
#4
ok so it turned out that the alternator has no problem at all rather the cells in my battery were weak due to drying out of the acid. In fact a series of test were done to confirm this and this include removing the negative terminal from the battery whiles the engine is still running and placing it back on. If there are not sparks whiles u palce the terminal on then the alternator is fine. Am sure this is a primitive way of checking but it really helps if u don't have all those digital stuff> Currently i have a new battery on and all seem to be going very well with no battery light on the dash.
#7
Once an engine is running, if the alternator is producing the battery is only a standby storage device. You should be able to pull the earth lead off, and you shouldn't get a spark unless the battery is flat.
The other point is that if the alternator was producing high on line voltage, it's working fine. The problem would be the regulator on the back of the alternator. Its job is to limit the output voltage so that the battery isn't overcharged, which will cause it to 'boil' and thus dry out the cells. Another indication that you may experience with a dud regulator is more frequent bulb failure where filament type lighting is in use. Bear in mind that modern alternators can have the regulating cicuitry built internally to the back of the alternator, so it may have to be removed to get to the problem.
As an aside, the most common cause of failure in alternators is brought on by bearing failure allowing the rotor to come into contact with the field coil and thus shorting out the alternator. I would personally strip the alternator down every 100,000miles & fit new bearings, which are quite cheap. You do need to take it to a workshop with a press to get the bearings both off & on, but other than that, they are pretty simple to overhaul. Most 'caged' ball bearings will comfortably last that long under such usage, and it's much cheaper than buying a new or reconditioned alternator. If the alternator is not of 'brushless' design, replace the brushes at the same time. They wear, and lose operating tension because of this. The armature may need dressing at the same time.
cheers,
Languid
The other point is that if the alternator was producing high on line voltage, it's working fine. The problem would be the regulator on the back of the alternator. Its job is to limit the output voltage so that the battery isn't overcharged, which will cause it to 'boil' and thus dry out the cells. Another indication that you may experience with a dud regulator is more frequent bulb failure where filament type lighting is in use. Bear in mind that modern alternators can have the regulating cicuitry built internally to the back of the alternator, so it may have to be removed to get to the problem.
As an aside, the most common cause of failure in alternators is brought on by bearing failure allowing the rotor to come into contact with the field coil and thus shorting out the alternator. I would personally strip the alternator down every 100,000miles & fit new bearings, which are quite cheap. You do need to take it to a workshop with a press to get the bearings both off & on, but other than that, they are pretty simple to overhaul. Most 'caged' ball bearings will comfortably last that long under such usage, and it's much cheaper than buying a new or reconditioned alternator. If the alternator is not of 'brushless' design, replace the brushes at the same time. They wear, and lose operating tension because of this. The armature may need dressing at the same time.
cheers,
Languid
The following users liked this post:
iownme (01-27-2012)
Trending Topics
#8
#9
Perez is right. The alternator is controlled by the motor ECU and generates 15.3 V when the engine is cold and in several other rapid charge conditions. A warm engine should have 13.5 to 14 V. This is more complex than a simple alternator.
P.S. Disconnecting the battery on a modern running engine is asking for DISASTER.
P.S. Disconnecting the battery on a modern running engine is asking for DISASTER.
#10
#12
I took the car to my cousin's garage. He is the manager at a garage in town which is a college town, and it is one of the two garages that operate on foreign cars. So I happen to have an advantage. Anyhow back to the story, he just hooked a machine up to the battery and we did a full test, involved turning my blowers on high, my high-beams on and my heated seats and such. And whenever they were all on, it was running at average voltage. But whenever it was all off, it was running too high of a voltage. You can also take your car to any auto parts store and they can do this as well. Such as Advance Auto Parts.
#13
Which almost certainly means the the regulator on the alternator is what is actually faulty, not the alternator itself. It's clearly working well, producing current, but the voltage is out of control. By replacing the alternator in total, you are actually throwing the baby out with the bath water.
Cheers,
Languid
Cheers,
Languid
#14
I took the car to my cousin's garage. He is the manager at a garage in town which is a college town, and it is one of the two garages that operate on foreign cars. So I happen to have an advantage. Anyhow back to the story, he just hooked a machine up to the battery and we did a full test, involved turning my blowers on high, my high-beams on and my heated seats and such. And whenever they were all on, it was running at average voltage. But whenever it was all off, it was running too high of a voltage. You can also take your car to any auto parts store and they can do this as well. Such as Advance Auto Parts.
Languid, the X Type alternator has two charge modes controlled by the ECU so it will look like a regulator problem.
Last edited by Tony_H; 01-26-2012 at 09:23 AM.
#15
#16
As Languid points out, there is a regulation problem. And, Tony_H says that regulation is externally influenced by the ECU and the perception of demand by the ECU. That makes the testing more complex, and the tester must account for the ECU influence.
There are many situations where a charging problem can be fixed without replacing the entire unit. A self rebuilt unit is often better than taking a crapshoot on a purchased rebuilt.
There are many situations where a charging problem can be fixed without replacing the entire unit. A self rebuilt unit is often better than taking a crapshoot on a purchased rebuilt.
The following users liked this post:
iownme (01-27-2012)
#17
I know I'll never convince QuintonChester, but for the rest of us on Page 52 of this link there is an explanation of how the charging system works.
$LU %DJ 0RGXOHV
This is a great document and it used to be on the FAQ but has now been replaced by a later and less useful version.
$LU %DJ 0RGXOHV
This is a great document and it used to be on the FAQ but has now been replaced by a later and less useful version.
The following users liked this post:
iownme (01-27-2012)
#18
I don't know why everybody is criticizing me, it's great to know that I'm the bad guy here... Anyway, I drove to my girlfriend's house today, and my car straight out died. Wouldn't turn over at all, jumped the car and my battery light came on instantly as well as my engine light. No clue what in the world is wrong with my cat :/ My alternator is already on the way though, and was on the way before this happened. Any clues?
#19
#20
QuintonChester, you're not "the bad guy" but I was insistent that the readings you were posting were within specifications. At the least you might have been wasting your money. That said, this is a public forum and we owe it to others not to post erroneous information. By all doing that we will get good information when we need it.
Sorry that your car has died.
Sorry that your car has died.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
03, 04, alternator, battery, c12, cars, caterpillar, charging, check, dying, jaguar, lnow, overcharging, replaced, type
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)