coolant temperature during cruising
#1
coolant temperature during cruising
I'm curious if anyone else has monitored their coolant temp (on a scan tool) while driving on the highway. I had issues with my cooling system in the past, so I occasionally watched it with the scan tool just to check up on things.
What I noticed about this car, the coolant temp will stay 197 F during the winter. But in the summer, cruising on the highway the temp will go higher (200-205). I realize that the thermostat "starts opening at 190 and is fully open at 210", but I've never seen another car that increased temperature when it has 75 mph ram air blowing over the radiator.
I know it's perfectly normal for coolant to go to 205 F when idling through traffic, but on all other cars I've checked it usually drops back down to 195 and stays there once moving again.
Debating whether this is normal for this car, or if I should try another thermostat and see if it regulates the temperature better.
What I noticed about this car, the coolant temp will stay 197 F during the winter. But in the summer, cruising on the highway the temp will go higher (200-205). I realize that the thermostat "starts opening at 190 and is fully open at 210", but I've never seen another car that increased temperature when it has 75 mph ram air blowing over the radiator.
I know it's perfectly normal for coolant to go to 205 F when idling through traffic, but on all other cars I've checked it usually drops back down to 195 and stays there once moving again.
Debating whether this is normal for this car, or if I should try another thermostat and see if it regulates the temperature better.
#3
It all depends on which engine you have
I have the 4.2 s/c with a low temp thermostat
Normal temp is 91c and it will rarely vary on the road.
With that said I live in the tropics so a cold in winter is +25c but summer can get into the 40c+
The only time I get higher temps is on the track and I can push the temps to around 95c
The difference with the thermostat change is I was pushing the temps to 110c on the track with the oem thermostat. Also it takes a lot longer to warm up it gets to +60 fairly quick then slows down it takes about 15mins of driving to get above 80c and reaches 90c after about 30mins.
Cheers
34by151
I have the 4.2 s/c with a low temp thermostat
Normal temp is 91c and it will rarely vary on the road.
With that said I live in the tropics so a cold in winter is +25c but summer can get into the 40c+
The only time I get higher temps is on the track and I can push the temps to around 95c
The difference with the thermostat change is I was pushing the temps to 110c on the track with the oem thermostat. Also it takes a lot longer to warm up it gets to +60 fairly quick then slows down it takes about 15mins of driving to get above 80c and reaches 90c after about 30mins.
Cheers
34by151
#4
It's the 4.2 N/A with the OE thermostat. The tstat housing is not broken internally, that was replaced already.
I regularly see 95 C (205 F) in summer driving even on the highway, but never above that.
I regularly see 95 C (205 F) in summer driving even on the highway, but never above that.
It all depends on which engine you have
I have the 4.2 s/c with a low temp thermostat
Normal temp is 91c and it will rarely vary on the road.
With that said I live in the tropics so a cold in winter is +25c but summer can get into the 40c+
The only time I get higher temps is on the track and I can push the temps to around 95c
The difference with the thermostat change is I was pushing the temps to 110c on the track with the oem thermostat. Also it takes a lot longer to warm up it gets to +60 fairly quick then slows down it takes about 15mins of driving to get above 80c and reaches 90c after about 30mins.
Cheers
34by151
I have the 4.2 s/c with a low temp thermostat
Normal temp is 91c and it will rarely vary on the road.
With that said I live in the tropics so a cold in winter is +25c but summer can get into the 40c+
The only time I get higher temps is on the track and I can push the temps to around 95c
The difference with the thermostat change is I was pushing the temps to 110c on the track with the oem thermostat. Also it takes a lot longer to warm up it gets to +60 fairly quick then slows down it takes about 15mins of driving to get above 80c and reaches 90c after about 30mins.
Cheers
34by151
#5
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,255 Likes
on
1,840 Posts
#6
Yes, it may be working just fine, but I will conclude that myself after I hear other people tell me their cars normally run 200-210 F on the highway.
#7
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,255 Likes
on
1,840 Posts
Trending Topics
#8
#9
Originally Posted by JagV8
Suppose it's not normal. It would have to be something like lack of coolant flow. Broken water pump?
I suppose if I'm really curious I can buy a new tstat and try it on the car, see if there's any difference in regulating temperature. Otherwise I'd have to assume like Mikey said that this is the normal operating temp for this engine setup.
#10
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,255 Likes
on
1,840 Posts
While it's logical to assume that there's more airflow across a rad at highway speeds than while stopped, the volume of heat being created also changes. An undersized rad might be adequate in the city but not big enough for highway duty.
The science/art of balanced cooling systems is far more complex than imagined.
#11
I'm going to assume this car has pretty decent aerodynamics, and with the undertray and baffles in place it should create a low pressure zone that pulls air through the radiator at cruising speed.
I was watching the coolant temp on my way home today. 80F ambient, ac set to 72F. Cruising at 70 mph the coolant temp was 195F. I gave it a little gas to pass a car, dropped to 5th gear for 3 seconds to get to 75 mph (rpm went from 2000 to 2300), the temp jumped immediately to 200 F. Then slowly decreased back to 195F after 15-20 seconds. That makes no sense to me, unless there's some poor coolant flow within the engine, and somehow the sensor got a burst of hot coolant when it rev'd 300 rpm? No idea there.
Got off the highway, sat at a stoplight it rose to 205 F. Driving 35-45 mph in moving traffic the temps stayed at 200-205.
I guess those numbers are okay--looking back at my Cadillac FSM, fans go on low speed at 220F, high speed at 230F (if not using a/c), and I've never seen over 210F in this car. Maybe it is operating normally... but that's why I was asking if anyone else sees the same temps on their vehicle.
I was watching the coolant temp on my way home today. 80F ambient, ac set to 72F. Cruising at 70 mph the coolant temp was 195F. I gave it a little gas to pass a car, dropped to 5th gear for 3 seconds to get to 75 mph (rpm went from 2000 to 2300), the temp jumped immediately to 200 F. Then slowly decreased back to 195F after 15-20 seconds. That makes no sense to me, unless there's some poor coolant flow within the engine, and somehow the sensor got a burst of hot coolant when it rev'd 300 rpm? No idea there.
Got off the highway, sat at a stoplight it rose to 205 F. Driving 35-45 mph in moving traffic the temps stayed at 200-205.
I guess those numbers are okay--looking back at my Cadillac FSM, fans go on low speed at 220F, high speed at 230F (if not using a/c), and I've never seen over 210F in this car. Maybe it is operating normally... but that's why I was asking if anyone else sees the same temps on their vehicle.
#12
To be honest an increase of 5°F (a shade less than 3°C) is pretty small.
I don't think you'd pay much attention to it if it were on an analog dial, a proper one with a continuous range, say 65°C/150°F to 125°C/250°F.
If it were a proper dial with 270 degree angle dial min-to-max, 150-to-250 °F, then an increase of 5°F is a change in needle angle of 14 degrees, that's less than half the angle between the numerals on a clock face.
On a 120-ish degree angle dial, like the one on the X350, you'd hardly notice it.
I don't think you'd pay much attention to it if it were on an analog dial, a proper one with a continuous range, say 65°C/150°F to 125°C/250°F.
If it were a proper dial with 270 degree angle dial min-to-max, 150-to-250 °F, then an increase of 5°F is a change in needle angle of 14 degrees, that's less than half the angle between the numerals on a clock face.
On a 120-ish degree angle dial, like the one on the X350, you'd hardly notice it.
Last edited by Partick the Cat; 03-15-2016 at 07:12 PM.
#13
I'm going to assume this car has pretty decent aerodynamics, and with the undertray and baffles in place it should create a low pressure zone that pulls air through the radiator at cruising speed.
I was watching the coolant temp on my way home today. 80F ambient, ac set to 72F. Cruising at 70 mph the coolant temp was 195F. I gave it a little gas to pass a car, dropped to 5th gear for 3 seconds to get to 75 mph (rpm went from 2000 to 2300), the temp jumped immediately to 200 F. Then slowly decreased back to 195F after 15-20 seconds. That makes no sense to me, unless there's some poor coolant flow within the engine, and somehow the sensor got a burst of hot coolant when it rev'd 300 rpm? No idea there.
Got off the highway, sat at a stoplight it rose to 205 F. Driving 35-45 mph in moving traffic the temps stayed at 200-205.
I guess those numbers are okay--looking back at my Cadillac FSM, fans go on low speed at 220F, high speed at 230F (if not using a/c), and I've never seen over 210F in this car. Maybe it is operating normally... but that's why I was asking if anyone else sees the same temps on their vehicle.
I was watching the coolant temp on my way home today. 80F ambient, ac set to 72F. Cruising at 70 mph the coolant temp was 195F. I gave it a little gas to pass a car, dropped to 5th gear for 3 seconds to get to 75 mph (rpm went from 2000 to 2300), the temp jumped immediately to 200 F. Then slowly decreased back to 195F after 15-20 seconds. That makes no sense to me, unless there's some poor coolant flow within the engine, and somehow the sensor got a burst of hot coolant when it rev'd 300 rpm? No idea there.
Got off the highway, sat at a stoplight it rose to 205 F. Driving 35-45 mph in moving traffic the temps stayed at 200-205.
I guess those numbers are okay--looking back at my Cadillac FSM, fans go on low speed at 220F, high speed at 230F (if not using a/c), and I've never seen over 210F in this car. Maybe it is operating normally... but that's why I was asking if anyone else sees the same temps on their vehicle.
#14
It is really hard to find an used radiator even from the scrapyard without paying hundreds of euros
So what I will do next is I will put the hoses off and connect the cooler to a pump which is normally used to pump the water from the river into the garden (well the flowers need water and the water from the river is for free ).
I will pump clean warm water with a bit of citric resolver through the radiator.
Then I will see whether the water at the output is clean or not and how much water comes out of the outlet.
I will keep you all informed =]
So what I will do next is I will put the hoses off and connect the cooler to a pump which is normally used to pump the water from the river into the garden (well the flowers need water and the water from the river is for free ).
I will pump clean warm water with a bit of citric resolver through the radiator.
Then I will see whether the water at the output is clean or not and how much water comes out of the outlet.
I will keep you all informed =]
#17
I want to refresh the topic. I have a problem with my thermostat, but strangely in the opposite direction. In a traffic jam, the temperature on the gauges reaches 90 degrees. A computer reading confirms the operating temperature is normal. When I drive above 75 mph the temperature drops to about 82 degrees Celsius. A year ago I replaced a new radiator and expansion fluid tank. Now I have replaced the thermostat. First, the replacement and the readings were the same. Later I replaced it with the original thermostat. The readings were also the same. I replaced the coolant, but it didn't change anything. Do you have any ideas for my case?
#18
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: Northern Virginia and Hong Kong
Posts: 711
Received 149 Likes
on
132 Posts
I want to refresh the topic. I have a problem with my thermostat, but strangely in the opposite direction. In a traffic jam, the temperature on the gauges reaches 90 degrees. A computer reading confirms the operating temperature is normal. When I drive above 75 mph the temperature drops to about 82 degrees Celsius. A year ago I replaced a new radiator and expansion fluid tank. Now I have replaced the thermostat. First, the replacement and the readings were the same. Later I replaced it with the original thermostat. The readings were also the same. I replaced the coolant, but it didn't change anything. Do you have any ideas for my case?
Suggest some detective work on that possibility, most especially, as you have recently done cooling system work.
Low cost for the easy-to-use test gear. High cost if the engine is damaged. == Readily justifiable spend.
Last edited by Thermite; 04-04-2024 at 06:05 PM.
#19
#20
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: Northern Virginia and Hong Kong
Posts: 711
Received 149 Likes
on
132 Posts
5.0 AJ133 fitted to the Rover is worse as to air bleeding than the 4.2 in the Jaguar, (I have one of each), but both are subject to the trapped air problem, even with three bleed points.
It was the 2005 XJ8-L that was driving me bonkers with the sudden DROP in temps on 75 MPH interstate over about a 70 mile trip. Not until a day when it suddenly jumped UP from just above the blue 'cold' range to red overheat range did I twig to what was afoot. Once I got the AIR out of it, it became apparent that the coolant actually WAS low, and had been since the previous antifreeze change - fortunately very recent at that time.
As to the tools and method I researched and adopted AFTERWARDS:
Pressure and vaccum test on the cooling system, and each held for a significant period of time, can help detect even VERY slow leakage. Annnnnd - what we are looking for that relates to our mystery cooling - trapped air. Cheap kit, that one, but identifying a problem is not the same as resolving the problem.
A vacuum charging system additionally can be used to introduce coolant without the hassle of trapped air arising in the first place.
Common item in modern dealership & indy garages. More spend, but not that much more. Annnnd it can do the job of the cheaper one. Had I but bought it FIRST, I'd have saved a few bob.
My one, not terribly expensive, is operated by venturi effect off a small 'pancake' air compressor I was otherwise using to drive nails. Easier to get it near the vehicle than the big compressor, and the kit doesn't need much air to do its job anyway.
"The usual suspects" carry these, usually made in China,.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/354990966486
...but .... I don't do this work for any but my own two vehicles, and not very often, even so, ergo they have proven more than good enough.
Last edited by Thermite; 04-05-2024 at 05:26 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
vdpnyc
XJ XJ8 / XJR ( X308 )
10
12-12-2013 03:02 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)