I think it is hard to match the style of the factory wheel offerings.

I have aftermarket on my Jaguar.
The originals were not bad, but even with newly balanced tires it was never quite right.
Went away with new wheels.
I'll want to repair/refinish the stock ones someday.

Fidning a good aftermarket wheel was a huge time sink, and I ended up going for performance/strength without as much consideration to style.
That let me hit the buy button, as my 2nd set of tires were bald and I needed action now.